Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Horwath" data-source="post: 9373374" data-attributes="member: 6801299">Why not free for all?half feat just means that the feat cannot stand on it's own with mechanics and it's not worth a full feat slot.OK, we come from opposite sides of this.To me feat &quot;slot&quot; should be:+2 ASI,+1/+1 ASI,1x full feat,+1 ASI, 1xhalf feat,2x half feat,even with adding CON, you now are at situation that you have to start with 15 or 13 Con so you can &quot;fix&quot; that at 4th level or later, because odd scores are worthless except as a stepping stone to next improvement in modifier and that happens in 99% when pushing primary stat from 17 to 20.no, it is really not. it just forces people to pre-plan their point buy more.well, from my Hema experience, you need certain amount of STR to parry or attacker will just break through your guard.if feats have fixed ASIs then having them balanced as much as possible should be the goal, again if you have all with floating +1, then you remove this problem in design and can focus on more important things.then add Arcana proficiency to the feat if you want to know your (spellcasting) enemy.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Horwath, post: 9373374, member: 6801299"] Why not free for all? half feat just means that the feat cannot stand on it's own with mechanics and it's not worth a full feat slot. OK, we come from opposite sides of this. To me feat "slot" should be: +2 ASI, +1/+1 ASI, 1x full feat, +1 ASI, 1xhalf feat, 2x half feat, even with adding CON, you now are at situation that you have to start with 15 or 13 Con so you can "fix" that at 4th level or later, because odd scores are worthless except as a stepping stone to next improvement in modifier and that happens in 99% when pushing primary stat from 17 to 20. no, it is really not. it just forces people to pre-plan their point buy more. well, from my Hema experience, you need certain amount of STR to parry or attacker will just break through your guard. if feats have fixed ASIs then having them balanced as much as possible should be the goal, again if you have all with floating +1, then you remove this problem in design and can focus on more important things. then add Arcana proficiency to the feat if you want to know your (spellcasting) enemy. [/QUOTE]

Verification