Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Mike Sullivan" data-source="post: 1003773" data-attributes="member: 9824">Yes, I've run the numbers before and will again:1.45 ( 5 + x) > 1.3 ( 7 + x)7.25 + 1.45x > 9.1 + 1.3x.15x > 1.85x > 12.333...Thus, in 3.0, assuming an imp crit, keen weapon for both parties, once your total damage bonus (including strength, feats, magic, etc) is +13 or greater, against an opponent susceptible to critical hits, it's advantageous to use a scythe or falchion over a greatsword.In 3.5, the equation is:1.3 ( 5 + x) > 1.2 (7 + x)6.5 + 1.3x > 8.4 + 1.2x.1x > 1.9x > 19Thus, in 3.5, assuming either imp. crit or keen for both parties, once your total damage bonus (including strength, feats, magic, etc) is +20 or greater, against an opponent susceptible to critical hits, it's advantageous to use a scythe or falchion over a greatsword.For rapiers/picks vs. longswords:3.0:1.45 ( 3.5 + x) > 1.3 (4.5 + x)5.075 + 1.45x > 5.85 + 1.3x.15x > .775x > 5.16666...So it's advantageous once your damage bonus is +6 or higher.  (Assuming all the conditions spelled out above).3.5:1.3 ( 3.5 + x) > 1.2 (4.5 + x)4.55 + 1.3x > 5.4 + 1.2x.1x > .85x > 8.5So it's advantageous once your damage bonus is +9 or higher.  (Again, assuming all the conditions).I think that's the best way to get the comparison you're looking for -- basically, you need to get an additional +3 to damage for a rapier or heavy pick, or a +7 to damage for a falchion or scythe.  Note that these are the minimum damage bonuses for it to EVER make sense to use the better-crit weapons.  It's still arguably a bad idea to use a rapier if your damage bonus is +10 in 3.5, because you'll do, on average, about .15 hp more damage per attack against an opponent susceptible to crits, but -1 hp less damage per attack against an opponent not susceptible to crits.EDIT:  The other way of saying this is that the effective damage output of high-crit weapons (rapier, picks, etc) was reduced by 15%, the effective damage output of medium-crit weapons (longsword, battleaxe) was reduced by 10%, and the effective damage output of low-crit weapons (clubs, fists) was reduced by 5%.  Assuming that you'd bother to get both keen and imp. critical for the 3.0 version of each such weapon.</blockquote>

Verification