Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Milambus" data-source="post: 4516933" data-attributes="member: 74238">4e is a game system that defines what you can do, not what you can not do.  So, show me the rule that states you can do this.Some quotes from PHB pg 215:Not too much meat there, but it gives us a starting definition.  In the next paragraph:These are weapons with the Off-Hand property.And these are weapons with the Versatile property.No where in there does it say that all one-handed weapons can be wielded with two-hands.  The pommel of a weapon is only so large.  For one-handed weapons its just large enough for one hand.  For Versatile weapons it a bit larger, allowing the second hand to fit.  For a two-handed weapon it can be even larger, allowing both hands to fit easily perhaps with some space between them.Look at the picture of a scimitar on pg 217.  Where does a second hand fit on that?Actually, I think in my last quote from the PHB above shows that a Versatile weapon could indeed meet this requirement because it says that you are "using them as two-handed weapons."  That seems to say that for the purpose of this attack, the weapon in question is in fact a two-handed weapon.</blockquote>