Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Rocket your D&D 5E and Level Up: Advanced 5E games into space! Alpha Star Magazine Is Launching... Right Now!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Lanefan" data-source="post: 8051861" data-attributes="member: 29398">Agreed.However it's something the game has, sadly, never modelled very well at all.Case in point.A character at 1 hit point, unless one is all it ever has (which I don't think been possible since 1e), is about as close to being dead as it can be without in fact being dead; and thus should not be capable of doing everything as well as when it's at full health.  But the game's never gone into this much detail, leaving us with a much-too-binary system of you're either fully functional or you're dead.The 1e-2e solution of death at -10 and the area between 0 and -9 being a range of lessened functionality (or just unconsciousness, but even that's still too binary) actually solves a surprising number of these headaches.  But for some reason 5e doesn't want to track negative hit points, and so out the window goes that design opportunity.  Couple this binary on-off situation with a) an inability to go below zero and b) in-combat ranged healing and you've got Whack-A-Mole, which is truly ridiculous.I'm sure it does, and all's well as far as it goes.The problem is it's the rules themselves surrounding this that need help; and my point is they do need to be changed.  Not just death-and-dying rules but the whole resting/healing/recovery paradigm, never mind the relationship between hit points (as a percentage of one's maximum) and health and-or functionality.4e - an edition I rarely praise for anyhting - was on the right path with its bloodied mechanic: go below half your max hit points and something or some things changed.  There should also be changes at the 1/4 point, at the 1/10 point, and at 1 h.p. if you've 20 or more maximum; to reflect generally lowered functionality and - with some classes - increasing desperation.</blockquote>

Verification