Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Engilbrand" data-source="post: 4556630" data-attributes="member: 44184">Kleenex is now a generic name for any sort of &quot;facial tissue&quot;.For people who aren't familiar with D&amp;D, the statement, &quot;I play D&amp;D.&quot; means that that person gets together with other people, rolls dice, and pretends to be an elf or whatever.Among people who are familiar with RPGs and whatever, &quot;I play D&amp;D.&quot; means a bit more.If you're talking to people who play D&amp;D, the statement, &quot;I play D&amp;D.&quot; should net you a follow-up question of, &quot;Which edition?&quot;I still have yet to see 3 things from the many that I posted:1. Is America really America?2. What makes D&amp;D what it is?3. What makes 4th edition NOT D&amp;D?Don't argue semantics. These are very straightforward questions. If anyone feels strongly that 4th edition isn't D&amp;D, then they should be able to answer these questions in a way that makes sense. Also, attempting to flip them around back on the rest of us is ridiculous. The side of &quot;4th edition is D&amp;D&quot; has made its point. The other side has not.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Engilbrand, post: 4556630, member: 44184"] Kleenex is now a generic name for any sort of "facial tissue". For people who aren't familiar with D&D, the statement, "I play D&D." means that that person gets together with other people, rolls dice, and pretends to be an elf or whatever. Among people who are familiar with RPGs and whatever, "I play D&D." means a bit more. If you're talking to people who play D&D, the statement, "I play D&D." should net you a follow-up question of, "Which edition?" I still have yet to see 3 things from the many that I posted: 1. Is America really America? 2. What makes D&D what it is? 3. What makes 4th edition NOT D&D? Don't argue semantics. These are very straightforward questions. If anyone feels strongly that 4th edition isn't D&D, then they should be able to answer these questions in a way that makes sense. Also, attempting to flip them around back on the rest of us is ridiculous. The side of "4th edition is D&D" has made its point. The other side has not. [/QUOTE]

Verification