Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Greg K" data-source="post: 3707294" data-attributes="member: 5038">My take (and this is just as designers, I am sure they are all nice guys)Andy Collins:&nbsp;&nbsp; My favorite book is UA (but disliked that he admittedly&nbsp; let several things go in underdeveloped so that others can develop them). I liked Dragonomicon and Complete Warrior (the only complete book that is worth a damn now that the Spell Compendium has collected spells and domains).&nbsp; FInally,&nbsp; his website includes ideas that I think are , imo, more interesting&nbsp; than the majority of stuff&nbsp; coming out of WOTC.James Wyatt, I haven seen anything by him that I liked outside of a few Dragon articles and Heroes of Horror.&nbsp; He has been responsible for what I consider to be among the worst DND books Book of Exalted Deeds, Defenders of the Faith, and Magic of Incarnum. I even found Complete Divine to be less than unimpressive outside of the domains.Mike Mearls: The last thing that I saw from him which&nbsp; I liked was the Book of Iron Might.&nbsp; I disliked Iron Heroes, but was initially ecstatic about him joining WOTC based upon his work for AEG, FFG, Mongoose, and Book of Iron Might.&nbsp; Unfortunately, I have been unimpressed with his WOTC work including ToB: Bo9S, the PHB2 Knight class as well as his musing on monster design.&nbsp; Rob Heinsoo, no idea.&nbsp; Didn't he work on stuff for AEG?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Greg K, post: 3707294, member: 5038"] My take (and this is just as designers, I am sure they are all nice guys) Andy Collins: My favorite book is UA (but disliked that he admittedly let several things go in underdeveloped so that others can develop them). I liked Dragonomicon and Complete Warrior (the only complete book that is worth a damn now that the Spell Compendium has collected spells and domains). FInally, his website includes ideas that I think are , imo, more interesting than the majority of stuff coming out of WOTC. James Wyatt, I haven seen anything by him that I liked outside of a few Dragon articles and Heroes of Horror. He has been responsible for what I consider to be among the worst DND books Book of Exalted Deeds, Defenders of the Faith, and Magic of Incarnum. I even found Complete Divine to be less than unimpressive outside of the domains. Mike Mearls: The last thing that I saw from him which I liked was the Book of Iron Might. I disliked Iron Heroes, but was initially ecstatic about him joining WOTC based upon his work for AEG, FFG, Mongoose, and Book of Iron Might. Unfortunately, I have been unimpressed with his WOTC work including ToB: Bo9S, the PHB2 Knight class as well as his musing on monster design. Rob Heinsoo, no idea. Didn't he work on stuff for AEG? [/QUOTE]

Verification