Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Sacrosanct" data-source="post: 6659014" data-attributes="member: 15700">So when Hussar said he wanted to sunder the armor and do damage to a target, and said this:He was wrong?&nbsp; That it's not any easier in 4e than it is in any other edition because you're doing the same thing by coming up with your own rules to make it not extremely limiting (as RAW in 4e has it)?But either way, all this does is still support my overall point because as Hussar's post illustrates, if you have a defined power, you think you can do it and without it being defined, you might not even try.&nbsp; Which goes back to my assertion that the more defined things you have, the more limiting it is.&nbsp; I don't even need to point out the numerous examples of players who check their character sheets and if it isn't there they don't bother.&nbsp; We have an example right here where if there isn't a power specifically for it, then it's not even attempted.&nbsp; &quot;It won't even fly&quot; was the assumption made, when that's not really the case.&nbsp; I've already said how I would do it in AD&amp;DHence my analogy of the crayons, and why it's an apt one.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Sacrosanct, post: 6659014, member: 15700"] So when Hussar said he wanted to sunder the armor and do damage to a target, and said this: He was wrong? That it's not any easier in 4e than it is in any other edition because you're doing the same thing by coming up with your own rules to make it not extremely limiting (as RAW in 4e has it)? But either way, all this does is still support my overall point because as Hussar's post illustrates, if you have a defined power, you think you can do it and without it being defined, you might not even try. Which goes back to my assertion that the more defined things you have, the more limiting it is. I don't even need to point out the numerous examples of players who check their character sheets and if it isn't there they don't bother. We have an example right here where if there isn't a power specifically for it, then it's not even attempted. "It won't even fly" was the assumption made, when that's not really the case. I've already said how I would do it in AD&D Hence my analogy of the crayons, and why it's an apt one. [/QUOTE]

Verification