Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="C-F-K" data-source="post: 6859812" data-attributes="member: 6834515">Did someone drew the death card in his/her Tarokka deck and thought it would be the end for 5th? You know the death card isn't really about death right...?Let's give it another, let's say 10 years before we can compare the editions.My 2c:People liked AD&amp;D so much because it was extensive and detailed. You didn't only have the PHB to create your character, but also a book for almost each class, the psionics, detailed works on all the other planes (I ain't gettin' in no plane!) and more than 15 years of novels, adventures and what-nots.No, 5th edition isn't perfect. But what edition is? And still, if 5th becomes &quot;perfect&quot;, some people are still going to hate it because they have childhood memories of playing 1st, 2nd or AD&amp;D, and those can't be replaced.So no, I have only heard of people quitting AD&amp;D and started with 5th. And they (Including me) all agree, it's not perfect but it might be in the future.(Last note: If the game sucks, your playing it wrong...)</blockquote>

[QUOTE="C-F-K, post: 6859812, member: 6834515"] Did someone drew the death card in his/her Tarokka deck and thought it would be the end for 5th? You know the death card isn't really about death right...? Let's give it another, let's say 10 years before we can compare the editions. My 2c: People liked AD&D so much because it was extensive and detailed. You didn't only have the PHB to create your character, but also a book for almost each class, the psionics, detailed works on all the other planes (I ain't gettin' in no plane!) and more than 15 years of novels, adventures and what-nots. No, 5th edition isn't perfect. But what edition is? And still, if 5th becomes "perfect", some people are still going to hate it because they have childhood memories of playing 1st, 2nd or AD&D, and those can't be replaced. So no, I have only heard of people quitting AD&D and started with 5th. And they (Including me) all agree, it's not perfect but it might be in the future. (Last note: If the game sucks, your playing it wrong...) [/QUOTE]

Verification