Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="BryonD" data-source="post: 6551896" data-attributes="member: 957">That may be true for you.&nbsp; It is entirely not true for me.The rewards of the game itself (in addition to the social activity) are way different.Board Games to RPGs is Apples to Pizza.Honestly, if you don't get more out of RPGs than you do board games, then (IMO) you are not doing RPGs right.That isn't anything against board games or loving them.&nbsp; The same thing comment could fairly be made in reverse.But if Catan produces the same experience for you as an RPG, then you have no clue what I experience in RPGs and thus really can not offer any insight that will be relevant to me.You are missing the point.&nbsp; There are hundreds if not thousands of other board games.&nbsp;&nbsp; The vast majority fail, you are pointing at a release schedule as a key to success, when obviously the core game itself was a huge outlier in the field.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="BryonD, post: 6551896, member: 957"] That may be true for you. It is entirely not true for me. The rewards of the game itself (in addition to the social activity) are way different. Board Games to RPGs is Apples to Pizza. Honestly, if you don't get more out of RPGs than you do board games, then (IMO) you are not doing RPGs right. That isn't anything against board games or loving them. The same thing comment could fairly be made in reverse. But if Catan produces the same experience for you as an RPG, then you have no clue what I experience in RPGs and thus really can not offer any insight that will be relevant to me. You are missing the point. There are hundreds if not thousands of other board games. The vast majority fail, you are pointing at a release schedule as a key to success, when obviously the core game itself was a huge outlier in the field. [/QUOTE]

Verification