Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="FrogReaver" data-source="post: 9818686" data-attributes="member: 6795602">IMO if your critique is going to be filled with points about stuff as weak as Barbarian Weapon Mastery restrictions then it’s probably in your interest not to post those critiques as a bunch of weak sauce critiques usually undermines your credibility on the more important ones.To be fair, your criticism of it amounted to ‘barbarians are the only ones that have a restriction on weapon mastery to melee weapons and you personally find that bizarre since they have proficiency with ranged weapons’. Someone saying I don’t find that bizarre seems like a perfectly valid response. IMO.  I criticized 2024 in this very thread.  I didn’t get any pushback. I’ve seen others do the same. Maybe it’s not criticism is general but your specific criticisms that are being pushed back on?I’ll give another 2024 critique.  Classes in 2024 feel a lot stronger even at low levels.  Many would consider them feeling too strong which can detract from commonly desired roleplaying experiences. I think the problem was that your format incintivized you to try to find a criticism about every individual feature no matter how minor.</blockquote>