Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="BMF" data-source="post: 1127436" data-attributes="member: 3149">That's not what he said. &nbsp;That shows a flaw in your analysis. I submit exhibit A: &nbsp;I would never allow someone to play a fighter with that many feats. Clearly, they would be more powerful than any barbarian or paladin or ranger. You are making a dubious association between class abilities and feats. You also disregard the flexibility and versatility that comes with the fighter's broad selection of feats. &nbsp;I agree that fighters don't get enough skills to choose from. I hesitate to give them more skill points though. I don't think they should get Spot, Listen, Hide, AND Move Silently (or Sneak). That is a sweet skill set that is the domain of rogues and other extremely alert characters. Perhaps one or two of those. Spot being my personal choice. &nbsp;Knowledge (tactics) from d20 Modern would be good too. &nbsp;Can you show how a 20th level barbarian is clearly more powerful than a 20th level fighter (like you did with the prestige classes above)?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="BMF, post: 1127436, member: 3149"] That's not what he said. That shows a flaw in your analysis. I submit exhibit A: I would never allow someone to play a fighter with that many feats. Clearly, they would be more powerful than any barbarian or paladin or ranger. You are making a dubious association between class abilities and feats. You also disregard the flexibility and versatility that comes with the fighter's broad selection of feats. I agree that fighters don't get enough skills to choose from. I hesitate to give them more skill points though. I don't think they should get Spot, Listen, Hide, AND Move Silently (or Sneak). That is a sweet skill set that is the domain of rogues and other extremely alert characters. Perhaps one or two of those. Spot being my personal choice. Knowledge (tactics) from d20 Modern would be good too. Can you show how a 20th level barbarian is clearly more powerful than a 20th level fighter (like you did with the prestige classes above)? [/QUOTE]

Verification