Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="5ekyu" data-source="post: 7576676" data-attributes="member: 6919838">I agree except... I think its important to note two things.First...I can see cases where the large vs small matters enough to give advantage - as the core system already brings size into resolution in cases where height matters. So, as a specific case-by-case ruling 9n the fly, sure. Trying to tip over a statue - pushing from low on the base vs pushing from 10'up... yeah can see that. But say a grapple check leg grabbing small... that doesnt seem a good case. So if this is bring pushed as a general rule, not as case-by-case circumstances then it passes from on-the-spot into house rule (nothing wrong with house rules but should be known.)Second...&quot;Circumstances not related to a creature’s inherent capabilities provide it with an edge.&quot;This is from the DMG advantage rules as one of the cases where GMs should consider giving advantage. It seems the one most dead spot on to &quot;my size is bigger&quot; and so again we see that a flat-out default bonus advantage&nbsp; across checks is not in line with this guideline.Again, no problem with house rules or momentary rulings.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="5ekyu, post: 7576676, member: 6919838"] I agree except... I think its important to note two things. First... I can see cases where the large vs small matters enough to give advantage - as the core system already brings size into resolution in cases where height matters. So, as a specific case-by-case ruling 9n the fly, sure. Trying to tip over a statue - pushing from low on the base vs pushing from 10'up... yeah can see that. But say a grapple check leg grabbing small... that doesnt seem a good case. So if this is bring pushed as a general rule, not as case-by-case circumstances then it passes from on-the-spot into house rule (nothing wrong with house rules but should be known.) Second... "Circumstances not related to a creature’s inherent capabilities provide it with an edge." This is from the DMG advantage rules as one of the cases where GMs should consider giving advantage. It seems the one most dead spot on to "my size is bigger" and so again we see that a flat-out default bonus advantage across checks is not in line with this guideline. Again, no problem with house rules or momentary rulings. [/QUOTE]

Verification