Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="BryonD" data-source="post: 5452165" data-attributes="member: 957">Anecdotes are certainly just anecdotes.But if you are claiming that the overall impact of 3E was not huge, then I think you are either in denial or just unaware."3E was truly a golden age of D&D, a revival of all that was great from the early years of the game. Its too bad that same feeling and fervor couldnt happen for 4E." - Clark Peterson"Is 4E doing as well as 3E sales in 2001? Definitely not. That was the high point in a generation." - Joseph GoodmanAnd these quotes are from over a year ago.  (nearly two years)   The goalposts of the debate have moved a long way since then.You can, of course, just declare these quotes equally meaningless.  If you want to, knock yourself out.  The quotes don't prove anything, common sense and open eyes do that in this case.  But the quotes go much further than simple random gamer anecdotes.</blockquote>