Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="BryonD" data-source="post: 5454070" data-attributes="member: 957">As a further note, if we are comparing fluff to fluff, then I don't doubt this in the least.But, since fluff has nothing to do with system of choice, I'd be judging a comparison of editions on a basis of mechanical representation.  In your 4E homebrew the AC of a knight in armor and a bare chested pirate will both be based primarily on their challenge level.  That, as one tiny example among a million other related issues, are why I have no doubt that even if I LOVE your homebrew, I'd (personally) enjoying playing in it VASTLY more using a less gamist mechanical system.But, the story and flavor of your homebrew just might be the most awesome ever, as far as I know.</blockquote>