Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Theuderic" data-source="post: 396383" data-attributes="member: 7802"><p>A real mechanical benefit means it's in the books. If your players don't mind you &quot;winging&quot; it or using special rules of your own then by all means use 1st edition. If you want more rules so that more things have mechanical &quot;benefits&quot; then use the new ed. Basically it's all a matter of personal preference. My group is more into the story and we throw half the rules out the window sometimes if it makes for a more interesting game. Which is why I I probably wont spend the money on 3rd E in the near future. If I did, it would be to keep players coming to my table ( the few new ones that wont play 1st E no matter what) which I don't have a problem with, being a fair and creative DM helps too) Like I said it's all about personal taste. 3rd E is not a &quot;better&quot; way to do anything as is any other edition. This is what I've found out from this thread. It took the man who created the game to help me see it.</p></blockquote><p></p>

[QUOTE="Theuderic, post: 396383, member: 7802"] A real mechanical benefit means it's in the books. If your players don't mind you "winging" it or using special rules of your own then by all means use 1st edition. If you want more rules so that more things have mechanical "benefits" then use the new ed. Basically it's all a matter of personal preference. My group is more into the story and we throw half the rules out the window sometimes if it makes for a more interesting game. Which is why I I probably wont spend the money on 3rd E in the near future. If I did, it would be to keep players coming to my table ( the few new ones that wont play 1st E no matter what) which I don't have a problem with, being a fair and creative DM helps too) Like I said it's all about personal taste. 3rd E is not a "better" way to do anything as is any other edition. This is what I've found out from this thread. It took the man who created the game to help me see it. [/QUOTE]

Verification