Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Psion" data-source="post: 396486" data-attributes="member: 172">Are apples better than oranges? Tough to say when you are talking about games that are doing different things.But when you start talking abuot games that strive to do the same thing, that argument begins to falter.It is pointless... because you insist on projecting your values on the game, and insist on repeating the same arguments. Open your eyes and you will there is a point.And note here, my point is not that 3e is the one true way, nor that you cannot have fun with 1e. My point is merely there is a general improvement in the mechanical implementation of 3e over 1e. If that's not a selling point for you, then fine.That depends. Are you having more fun because of some nostalgia factor or because of some quality of the game? Is there anything about the 1e game ITSELF that makes it more fun?I really don't think so.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Psion, post: 396486, member: 172"] Are apples better than oranges? Tough to say when you are talking about games that are doing different things. But when you start talking abuot games that strive to do the same thing, that argument begins to falter. It is pointless... because you insist on projecting your values on the game, and insist on repeating the same arguments. Open your eyes and you will there is a point. And note here, my point is not that 3e is the one true way, nor that you cannot have fun with 1e. My point is merely there is a general improvement in the mechanical implementation of 3e over 1e. If that's not a selling point for you, then fine. That depends. Are you having more fun because of some nostalgia factor or because of some quality of the game? Is there anything about the 1e game ITSELF that makes it more fun? I really don't think so. [/QUOTE]

Verification