Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Storm Raven" data-source="post: 399512" data-attributes="member: 307">You misundertand me I think. I did not mean that Lejendary Adventures would have to outsell 3e in order for their evidence that a Gygax designed new version of D&amp;D would outsell the current version. What I said was that one would look for Gygax's current game to be doing very well by industry standards in order to have good evidence.What I am saying is this: the general evidence is that Lejendary Adventures sells okay, but not necessarily great. I'd be surprised if it was in the top 5 of non-D&amp;D, non-White Wolf RPG lines sold today. Given that he does not appear to be outperforming his peers who have similarly limited brand recognition (and he has his own name recognition to help him out), I'm inclined to think that the evidence that he could produce a more popular version of 3e D&amp;D is rather weak.Impossible to tell. We can only draw conclusions from the evidence available, and the evidence available doesn't include anything that would be real helpful on this score.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Storm Raven, post: 399512, member: 307"] [B][/b] You misundertand me I think. I did not mean that Lejendary Adventures would have to outsell 3e in order for their evidence that a Gygax designed new version of D&D would outsell the current version. What I said was that one would look for Gygax's current game to be doing very well by industry standards in order to have good evidence. What I am saying is this: the general evidence is that Lejendary Adventures sells okay, but not necessarily great. I'd be surprised if it was in the top 5 of non-D&D, non-White Wolf RPG lines sold today. Given that he does not appear to be outperforming his peers who have similarly limited brand recognition (and he has his own [i]name[/i] recognition to help him out), I'm inclined to think that the evidence that he could produce a more popular version of 3e D&D is rather weak. Impossible to tell. We can only draw conclusions from the evidence available, and the evidence available doesn't include anything that would be real helpful on this score. [/QUOTE]

Verification