Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="ARandomGod" data-source="post: 2750475" data-attributes="member: 17296">I say get the smith who makes adamantine gauntlets to take on the job.Now you're cheating. Next thing you know you'll be suggesting that you use the spell to make masterwork full plate and ruin the economy... wait... that's already been suggested. ANYhow. It's pretty clear to me that a technology (magicology?) that can make any other thing out of adamantine can also make adamantine quarterstaffs...The next question is: Is that overpowered? And if so:&nbsp; How?It doesn't seem overpowered to me at all. I'd let it work. I prefer to say yes to new ideas unless I can see them not fitting into the proper power-level of the world. So another question I'd personally ask is: &quot;What justification do I have for saying &quot;no&quot;?&quot;If the only justification I can think of is &quot;Because it's new&quot; or &quot;Because I haven't thought of it&quot;, then I let it on in. If it turns out I missed the &quot;Because it makes an otherwise mundane skill/ability into something highly powerful that can't be replicated at anywhere near the price&quot;, well, I'll do something to make the problem go away.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="ARandomGod, post: 2750475, member: 17296"] I say get the smith who makes adamantine gauntlets to take on the job. Now you're cheating. Next thing you know you'll be suggesting that you use the spell to make masterwork full plate and ruin the economy... wait... that's already been suggested. ANYhow. It's pretty clear to me that a technology (magicology?) that can make any other thing out of adamantine can also make adamantine quarterstaffs... The next question is: Is that overpowered? And if so: How? It doesn't seem overpowered to me at all. I'd let it work. I prefer to say yes to new ideas unless I can see them not fitting into the proper power-level of the world. So another question I'd personally ask is: "What justification do I have for saying "no"?" If the only justification I can think of is "Because it's new" or "Because I haven't thought of it", then I let it on in. If it turns out I missed the "Because it makes an otherwise mundane skill/ability into something highly powerful that can't be replicated at anywhere near the price", well, I'll do something to make the problem go away. [/QUOTE]

Verification