Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Lamoni" data-source="post: 2782400" data-attributes="member: 12680">I didn't know I was saying this.&nbsp; They are seperate.&nbsp; Law/chaos is different from good/evil, but they both contribute to the alignment.&nbsp; Unless some special circumstances are present, an object is neutral.&nbsp; It is not lawful, chaotic, good, or evil.Anyway, let's seperate them and pretend that you could have an alignment that is just good with no law/chaos part (not even neutral).&nbsp; You still run into the same problem with a holy unholy sword.&nbsp; Once you put the first enhancement on it, it gains an alignment of good or evil.&nbsp; Then you couldn't place the second enhancement on it without destroying the first.&nbsp; If you could, you would end up with a good evil alignment.&nbsp; If you think that is allowed in the rules, please provide some evidence.&nbsp; And if it is allowed, I want to make a good evil character as my next PC.&nbsp; Could I add neutral to that too?&nbsp; Could I be a chaotic neutral lawful good neutral evil character?&nbsp; Are you sure this wouldn't require a houserule?Also, the only way someone could carry around a lawful evil sword is if it had both the axiomatic and unholy enhancements, or through the use of a spell.&nbsp; Making a normal sword into an unholy sword only changes the good/evil portion of the alignment so it would retain its law/chaos part.&nbsp; Since it is a normal sword that would make it neutral evil.&nbsp; If it was already an axiomatic sword, that would change it from a lawful neutral sword into a lawful evil sword.&nbsp; It all seems pretty simple to me.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Lamoni, post: 2782400, member: 12680"] I didn't know I was saying this. They are seperate. Law/chaos is different from good/evil, but they both contribute to the alignment. Unless some special circumstances are present, an object is neutral. It is not lawful, chaotic, good, or evil. Anyway, let's seperate them and pretend that you could have an alignment that is just good with no law/chaos part (not even neutral). You still run into the same problem with a holy unholy sword. Once you put the first enhancement on it, it gains an alignment of good or evil. Then you couldn't place the second enhancement on it without destroying the first. If you could, you would end up with a good evil alignment. If you think that is allowed in the rules, please provide some evidence. And if it is allowed, I want to make a good evil character as my next PC. Could I add neutral to that too? Could I be a chaotic neutral lawful good neutral evil character? Are you sure this wouldn't require a houserule? Also, the only way someone could carry around a lawful evil sword is if it had both the axiomatic and unholy enhancements, or through the use of a spell. Making a normal sword into an unholy sword only changes the good/evil portion of the alignment so it would retain its law/chaos part. Since it is a normal sword that would make it neutral evil. If it was already an axiomatic sword, that would change it from a lawful neutral sword into a lawful evil sword. It all seems pretty simple to me. [/QUOTE]

Verification