Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Bedrockgames" data-source="post: 9454754" data-attributes="member: 85555">I don't think anyone is saying it doesn't look like it was made in an earlier time. It is definitely a film made in an earlier style, though for its time it was pretty forward looking, and I think the visual composition of the film really holds up. I just think we have very different tastes here. I feel like George's edits in many instances ruined the shot composition and made the films look sloppy. Not saying you or others ought to agree, I just think he took this too far. That new death star explosion in particular I find off-putting. The thing about the edits they started making in the 90s is when it first came out in the theaters to fanfare it was pretty cool because it felt novel. But i didnt' realize they were basically replacing the original films with the changes. The worse change of course is what they did to Sy Snootles. That will not stand I don't take any offense at all. I'd rather you say how you feel than try to not rain on our parade. I don't agree with your viewpoint on these movies but if it is your honest opinion, better to share it than to lie about how you feel</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Bedrockgames, post: 9454754, member: 85555"] I don't think anyone is saying it doesn't look like it was made in an earlier time. It is definitely a film made in an earlier style, though for its time it was pretty forward looking, and I think the visual composition of the film really holds up. I just think we have very different tastes here. I feel like George's edits in many instances ruined the shot composition and made the films look sloppy. Not saying you or others ought to agree, I just think he took this too far. That new death star explosion in particular I find off-putting. The thing about the edits they started making in the 90s is when it first came out in the theaters to fanfare it was pretty cool because it felt novel. But i didnt' realize they were basically replacing the original films with the changes. The worse change of course is what they did to Sy Snootles. That will not stand I don't take any offense at all. I'd rather you say how you feel than try to not rain on our parade. I don't agree with your viewpoint on these movies but if it is your honest opinion, better to share it than to lie about how you feel [/QUOTE]

Verification