Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Niccodaemus" data-source="post: 5779546" data-attributes="member: 6683506">I would say  that since the setting is fantasy, any "moral code" you come up with should be fine, as long as there is some consistency for the players to be able to figure out. There might be a small kingdom with an Alice in Wonderland sense of morality as a constantly moving target, which can be fun, but overall, it should be predictable.I also prefer a moral culture that players can relate to. This is a game after all, and supposed to be fun.It is also a world with issues quite different from our own. The very nature of magic and treasure hunting opens up "moral issues" that can be treated quite differently in each game world. Animate Dead, tomb robbing, and even charm can all be looked at through different lenses.I've never liked the alignment descriptions in D&D, and tend to hand wave it away. In my book, the D&D alignment of "Neutral" is actually "Evil". "Evil" in D&D is sociopathy.This actually fits with the concept of the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_deadly_sins" target="_blank">Seven Deadly Sins.</a>, particularly from a medieval perspective.The entire subject touches on the concept of the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banality_of_evil" target="_blank">Banality of Evil</a>. Basically, that when living in an evil society, that people will accept evil as "normal".In the campaign world I'm designing, all magic is accomplished through the summoning of spirits (either spirits of the dead, or elemental and demon/devil types). The very act of magic is fraught with the potential for evil.An interesting approach might be to have demons that thrive on the misfortune of others show up from time to time, in various guises, and goad the PCs into actions which are ok by societal norms. This would be a sort of Faustian type of scenario, where the gloating of the demon could highlight the context of an action.Lets take that Lawful Good Guard. If the PCs try to interfere with his dispensation of Justice, the demon could appear as an old beggar or some such character, who radiates an unnatural aura. He might then provide a perfectly rational argument for the Guard's behavior, but suddenly the PCs might start to question their acceptance of everything they see.I do think an OOC conversation about "what is evil?" would be appropriate in the early stages of any campaign.</blockquote>

Verification