Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Arnwyn" data-source="post: 2013569" data-attributes="member: 7701">"However, this requires _constructive_ criticism..." I did give _constructive_ criticism - specifically, I wanted to see an example of what you consider broken. Your review was unhelpful because all you did was spout out "broken" without any examples so readers can judge for themselves.I'm with ASEO on this one - that list is *exactly* what I want to see when some reviewer says something is "broken". Simply saying that isn't enough, as many people have wildly differing views on what is considered broken, and how badly. You need to list examples for us to be able to make an informed buying decision. There's no way I'm going to take some internet reviewer's word for it.For example, a couple of missing skill points does not constitute "broken" (to me), though it might to others. I need to know what you mean.Thanks for the details, that helps very much. (I don't expect a full list of everything that is broken, but I do expect a well-detailed example. If you are absolutely insistent on not putting it into a review because it would be "boring", maybe you can add it to the comments section right after the review?)</blockquote>