Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Imaro" data-source="post: 8281718" data-attributes="member: 48965">I think at this point the GM would have to improvise or explain to the players that they didn't expect their plan and they may need sometime to come up with something if/when it is implemented.  I don't think if I was a player I would want to spend the time, effort and energy coming up with a really good plan in order for the DM to say... NO, you can't succeed, because... reasons.  It's you clearly dictating that a plan, no matter how well thought out or how much the PC's want to enact it... is going to fail if you decide the game would be better (for whatever value we are using) if it didn't succeed.   Ok well let me ask this question... can they circumvent 10% of the adventure through good planning and strategy?  30%?  50%?  In other words how much of your adventure must they approach in the way you have deemed better and how much can they circumvent?  Also why do you get to decide this?</blockquote>