Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="pemerton" data-source="post: 9393718" data-attributes="member: 42582">Because, upthread, a poster asserted that it is not possible for a RPG to have a rule for resolving every declared action. And that assertion is mistakenYou may not be interested in that, or in thinking about how a RPG can be designed so that it has a rule for resolving every declared action. But others might be.Well, does D&D have a rule for resolving every declared action? It's not obvious to me that 5e D&D does. I certainly see a lot of discussion that seems to proceed from the premise that it doesn't.I'm not posting about Dungeon World, I'm posting about Apocalypse World. Someone who knows DW better than I do would be in a position to say whether or not it has a rule to resolve every declared action.And I'm not sure what you are saying we disagree about. Do you disagree that AW has a rule to resolve every declared action?Do you disagree with me that D&D 5e has no notion of "GM moves"? I mean, I've never heard anyone talk about them. If you think 5e D&D does have GM moves, where is the discussion of them to be found?</blockquote>