Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Just Another User" data-source="post: 4072869" data-attributes="member: 23516">As you certainly know there are situations where being able to move an extra 4 squares (sigh) is worth a little damage.But for those that have no problem groking the artful dodger variant of positioning strike, could someone being so kind to describe me how it works against:a stone golem a ozee a 30 feet long snakean incorporeal creature a gelatinous cubeor a number of other creatures that I could imagine, specifically creatures mindless, which can't reasonably be taunted or even bluffed, or that don't technically feel pain, or creatures which can't be phisically &quot;shoved&quot; or that deal some kind of damage or negative effect on touch or, well, you get it (I hope.)Halfling vs ogre, I can make it work, even if it hurts, the problem is that in D&amp;D you fight weirdest things than ogres and using some of the powers against some of the mosnters (crimson edge against a mummy?) would be excedingly weird, and there are onyl three way I can see to making then worksa) surgically remove my SoDb) something like nth pages of exceptions for every power/monster (&quot;you can't use power X against monster A, B, C&quot; or &quot;monster A is immune to powers x, y, z&quot;c) empowerer the rule 0 to pre-3e&nbsp; levels, something that I could even like but I can't see the 4e designers do it.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Just Another User, post: 4072869, member: 23516"] As you certainly know there are situations where being able to move an extra 4 squares (sigh) is worth a little damage. But for those that have no problem groking the artful dodger variant of positioning strike, could someone being so kind to describe me how it works against: a stone golem a ozee a 30 feet long snake an incorporeal creature a gelatinous cube or a number of other creatures that I could imagine, specifically creatures mindless, which can't reasonably be taunted or even bluffed, or that don't technically feel pain, or creatures which can't be phisically "shoved" or that deal some kind of damage or negative effect on touch or, well, you get it (I hope.) Halfling vs ogre, I can make it work, even if it hurts, the problem is that in D&D you fight weirdest things than ogres and using some of the powers against some of the mosnters (crimson edge against a mummy?) would be excedingly weird, and there are onyl three way I can see to making then works a) surgically remove my SoD b) something like nth pages of exceptions for every power/monster ("you can't use power X against monster A, B, C" or "monster A is immune to powers x, y, z" c) empowerer the rule 0 to pre-3e levels, something that I could even like but I can't see the 4e designers do it. [/QUOTE]

Verification