Jester David
Hero
Yeah, WotC tried to bring back boxed sets and then very quickly stopped.Wasn't Gardmore Abbey a boxed set? Looks like it only cost about $40, and it was done fairly recently.
I've read all the old info about TSR, but I think the big issue was that a) everything was a boxed set and b) they undercosted the sets. Not that they weren't feasible, just not appropriately priced.
If they worked WotC would have kept doing them and not moved to flimsy boxes (Shadowfell) before dropping altogether.
(not being familiar with Gardmore Abby I'm uncertain if the box was a 2e style box or a flimsy top opening thing like Shadowfell.)
--edit--
From this image it looks exactly like the flimsy Shadowfell box.

This type of box was barely thicker than a cover of a softcover book. Thinner than your average box of cereal.
Last edited: