Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Mistwell" data-source="post: 4030124" data-attributes="member: 2525">You inferred that, but I don't see how he implied it.  He said he assumed the OP didn't have playtesting experience.  That doesn't imply a lack of qualification to have an opinion.  But it's relevant to evaluating his opinion.  It's not a characteristic or belief, and it is on-topic.  We are talking about the opinions of playtesters, and the OP's experience as a playtester is a natural subject of conversation and not an ad hominem in that context.Indeed, however nobody called him a scoundrel, or questioned his characteristics or beliefs.  You have created a strawman.  Nobody made a claim about someone's characteristics or beliefs, but you have now repeatedly claimed they did and then attacked that position that was never claimed.</blockquote>