Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Shade" data-source="post: 3077346" data-attributes="member: 287">Just for fun, I thought we could start odds on each creature's chances of acceptance.&nbsp; Here are my predictions:Cave Fisher - 100 to 1 (might be too similar mechanically to the bonespear)Rot Grubs - 2 to 1 (classic, fills a niche not really covered, interesting new approach as a swarm)Scarecrow - 50 to 1Tabaxi - 500 to 1 (catlike humanoids?&nbsp; Just ask the rakasta how well that's going)Piercer - 1,000 to 1 (WotC disliked them so much that they created the darkmantle to replace them)Hammer Golem - 5 to 1&nbsp; (golems are always popular, and this one is interesting)Crystal Ooze - 500 to 1&nbsp; (aquatic oozes are fairly well-represented in 3E)Firedrake - 500 to 1&nbsp; (probably too similar to a wyrmling red dragon)Wolfwere - 500 to 1&nbsp; (they did the jackalwere, so there's a slim chance)Mustard Jelly - 2 to 1 (classic critter, unique abilities...it's a near-lock)Voadkyn - 100 to 1&nbsp; (not that different from the MMII forest giant)Magic Golem - 5 to 1&nbsp; (another interesting golem, and wild magic needs love)Pegataur - 500 to 1&nbsp; ( think they'll see &quot;winged centaur&quot; and move on)Giant Troll -&nbsp; 1,000,000 to 1&nbsp;&nbsp; (after the MMIII, I'd say the chance of seeing another troll is slimmer than the return of THACO)Urd - 500 to 1&nbsp; (people in other threads already think they are represented by winged dragonborn or kobolds with the winged creature template)Living Web - 20 to 1Al-mi-raj - 1,000 to 1&nbsp; (Unibunny...'nuff said)Baku - 500 to 1Guardian Familiar - 100 to 1Death Watch Beetle - 3 to 1 I think the mustard jelly, rot grubs, death watch beetle, hammer golem, magic golem, and living web have the best shots, in that order.I'll eat this thread if the giant troll or piercer is picked.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Shade, post: 3077346, member: 287"] Just for fun, I thought we could start odds on each creature's chances of acceptance. Here are my predictions: Cave Fisher - 100 to 1 (might be too similar mechanically to the bonespear) Rot Grubs - 2 to 1 (classic, fills a niche not really covered, interesting new approach as a swarm) Scarecrow - 50 to 1 Tabaxi - 500 to 1 (catlike humanoids? Just ask the rakasta how well that's going) Piercer - 1,000 to 1 (WotC disliked them so much that they created the darkmantle to replace them) Hammer Golem - 5 to 1 (golems are always popular, and this one is interesting) Crystal Ooze - 500 to 1 (aquatic oozes are fairly well-represented in 3E) Firedrake - 500 to 1 (probably too similar to a wyrmling red dragon) Wolfwere - 500 to 1 (they did the jackalwere, so there's a slim chance) Mustard Jelly - 2 to 1 (classic critter, unique abilities...it's a near-lock) Voadkyn - 100 to 1 (not that different from the MMII forest giant) Magic Golem - 5 to 1 (another interesting golem, and wild magic needs love) Pegataur - 500 to 1 ( think they'll see "winged centaur" and move on) Giant Troll - 1,000,000 to 1 (after the MMIII, I'd say the chance of seeing another troll is slimmer than the return of THACO) Urd - 500 to 1 (people in other threads already think they are represented by winged dragonborn or kobolds with the winged creature template) Living Web - 20 to 1 Al-mi-raj - 1,000 to 1 (Unibunny...'nuff said) Baku - 500 to 1 Guardian Familiar - 100 to 1 Death Watch Beetle - 3 to 1 I think the mustard jelly, rot grubs, death watch beetle, hammer golem, magic golem, and living web have the best shots, in that order. I'll eat this thread if the giant troll or piercer is picked. [/QUOTE]

Verification