Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Lyxen" data-source="post: 8516328" data-attributes="member: 7032025">You are making the usual mistake that because a tool is offered to create some types of NPCs, it dictates that this is the only way to create NPCs. The text specifically reads: &quot;In order to easily develop these personae, the tables below are offered for consideration.&quot; and &quot;Other NPCs can be developed randomly, or by a combination of random and considered selection.&quot;Moreover, to prove that you are even more incorrect, the first reference that you give points towards the Rogues Gallery, in which we find, in addition to NPC indeed based on character classes: Couatl, Ki-rin, Shedu, Liches. But also Sages, which are certainly not based on a PC class (they have a spell ability and level in that ability based on a class, but it does not make them member of a class).[ATTACH=full]150109[/ATTACH]So no, I was perfectly correct, nothing in AD&amp;D forces NPCs to be members of a class, and once more, you are &quot;forgetting&quot; Lubash.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Lyxen, post: 8516328, member: 7032025"] You are making the usual mistake that because a tool is offered to create some types of NPCs, it dictates that this is the only way to create NPCs. The text specifically reads: "In order to easily develop these personae, the tables below are offered for consideration." and "Other NPCs can be developed randomly, or by a combination of random and considered selection." Moreover, to prove that you are even more incorrect, the first reference that you give points towards the Rogues Gallery, in which we find, in addition to NPC indeed based on character classes: [B][U]Couatl, Ki-rin, Shedu, Liches[/U][/B]. But also Sages, which are certainly not based on a PC class (they have a spell ability and level in that ability based on a class, but it does not make them member of a class). [ATTACH type="full"]150109[/ATTACH] So no, I was perfectly correct, nothing in AD&D forces NPCs to be members of a class, and once more, you are "forgetting" Lubash. [/QUOTE]

Verification