Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="SavageRobby" data-source="post: 3771443" data-attributes="member: 51573">I waffled between &quot;I'm happy with the coverage&quot; and &quot;Its too early&quot;. I voted &quot;I'm happy&quot; because, well, as much as I'd like more details, I don't think they have them to give. I'm with Celebrim on some of his points, though. Its hard for me to take the designers seriously when they say &quot;We've fixed X&quot; when they're still developing and testing the fixes. I'd believe, &quot;We think X is a problem, and we're testing ways to fix it&quot;, because I think that would be far more accurate.I also have an intense distrust of their timeline. They're just starting external playtesting now? Unless they've figured out a way to print and distribute the books in record time at a low price, I'm not convinced the quality of the 1st release of the books is going to be up to snuff. I get this feeling they'll be rushing late second rules changes through editing to get them off to the printer in time, and that is the kind of thing that causes sloppy work (and revisions and errata).</blockquote>

[QUOTE="SavageRobby, post: 3771443, member: 51573"] I waffled between "I'm happy with the coverage" and "Its too early". I voted "I'm happy" because, well, as much as I'd like more details, I don't think they have them to give. I'm with Celebrim on some of his points, though. Its hard for me to take the designers seriously when they say "We've fixed X" when they're still [i]developing and testing[/i] the fixes. I'd believe, "We think X is a problem, and we're testing ways to fix it", because I think that would be far more accurate. I also have an intense distrust of their timeline. They're just starting external playtesting now? Unless they've figured out a way to print and distribute the books in record time at a low price, I'm not convinced the quality of the 1st release of the books is going to be up to snuff. I get this feeling they'll be rushing late second rules changes through editing to get them off to the printer in time, and that is the kind of thing that causes sloppy work (and revisions and errata). [/QUOTE]

Verification