Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Coroc" data-source="post: 7795661" data-attributes="member: 6895991">Not to criticize you, in the end do what you have fun with, but:You stat you plan your campaign to last about two years, that is a lot of time you have to live with a potentially bad decision then.There is no problem with a low power level aka roll stats with 3d6, if you adapt the monster and challenge difficulties accordingly.But there is a big problem with two things: You force people to eventually play a class they do not want to play or have a character with very un-optimal attributes. But let us assume that is not a problem for your players or you then there is the second:&nbsp; If dice fall stupid you end up with 4 wizards or any other stupidly unbalanced party. That for me would be the real showstopper and though I would be absolutely open for a low power game this point would make me say no.So at least allow the 3d6 to be attached to the attribute the player wants to, so sorted in any order that is my strong advice for you and I am sure your campaign will be fun and challenging then.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Coroc, post: 7795661, member: 6895991"] Not to criticize you, in the end do what you have fun with, but: You stat you plan your campaign to last about two years, that is a lot of time you have to live with a potentially bad decision then. There is no problem with a low power level aka roll stats with 3d6, if you adapt the monster and challenge difficulties accordingly. But there is a big problem with two things: You force people to eventually play a class they do not want to play or have a character with very un-optimal attributes. But let us assume that is not a problem for your players or you then there is the second: If dice fall stupid you end up with 4 wizards or any other stupidly unbalanced party. That for me would be the real showstopper and though I would be absolutely open for a low power game this point would make me say no. So at least allow the 3d6 to be attached to the attribute the player wants to, so sorted in any order that is my strong advice for you and I am sure your campaign will be fun and challenging then. [/QUOTE]

Verification