Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="5ekyu" data-source="post: 7490482" data-attributes="member: 6919838">Again the reasonable pre-amble to the unreasonable aspersion and declarations. You remain consistent.You may feel it is only the GMs place to question your character's mechanics. You may jump directly to it being a sign of an &quot;inexplicable and irrational&quot; type of GM.That is just your &quot;feeling&quot; on the matter, your expansion of player agency and not by any means any sort of definition that goes beyond that.that belief would get you out the door at my game, and i suspect many others, even tho i would likely approve every case of fluff you have described. But the belief that these are out of bounds for rational Gms and the tendency to jump to that conclusion as soon as it seems even a polite denial occurs... not the type of &quot;tension between player and Gm&quot; i invite to my table to inflict on my players.Might need to consider adding &quot;&quot;Player Agency&quot; is banned&quot; to my campaign pre-campaign info sheet now that i know this is what it has transformed to. It would give my players a laugh for sure. So it has entertainment value.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="5ekyu, post: 7490482, member: 6919838"] Again the reasonable pre-amble to the unreasonable aspersion and declarations. You remain consistent. You may feel it is only the GMs place to question your character's mechanics. You may jump directly to it being a sign of an "inexplicable and irrational" type of GM. That is just your "feeling" on the matter, your expansion of player agency and not by any means any sort of definition that goes beyond that. that belief would get you out the door at my game, and i suspect many others, even tho i would likely approve every case of fluff you have described. But the belief that these are out of bounds for rational Gms and the tendency to jump to that conclusion as soon as it seems even a polite denial occurs... not the type of "tension between player and Gm" i invite to my table to inflict on my players. Might need to consider adding ""Player Agency" is banned" to my campaign pre-campaign info sheet now that i know this is what it has transformed to. It would give my players a laugh for sure. So it has entertainment value. [/QUOTE]

Verification