Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Goumindong" data-source="post: 4779079" data-attributes="member: 70874">What in the world are you talking about.The bard has an ability that creates a mark. The ability says "is marked by ally". So the enemy knows he is marked by the ally. That is all he knows. He has not been affected by any power that might even hint at adding any more riders onto that relating to what the fighter can do.You have, earlier, explicitly said that the enemy knows that if it defects the fighter can whack it. But there is no text anywhere, ever that mentions that this would be the case. There is no text that gives the combat challenge ability to allies. There is no text that says "any mark assigned to the fighter has the following effect". There simply is not text that gives any sort of suggestion that the enemy would know he is going to get hit.Now, either there is some text that suggests that, or your interpretation fails. It fails because it produces a known false conclusion.Lets do a little exampleRound 1Fighter attacks enemy 1: Marks him. [At this point, what do you think enemy 1 knows?]Bard attacks enemy 2: Marks him, assigns the mark to the fighter[at this point, what do you think enemy 2 knows]Enemy 2 attacks bard: fighter whacks enemy 2 with CC [are you saying this is impossible? because you've said earlier it was possible. At this point what does enemy 2 know?]Enemy 1 attacks bard: nothing else happens</blockquote>