Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Zardnaar" data-source="post: 7425019" data-attributes="member: 6716779">Not 80% of the good 3pp (Kobolds, Goodman, Frog God, Paizo) probably better than 80% of the DMGuild stuff.&nbsp;Assuming of course you take away the uber production values and look at the adventure. Full colour art is nice but B/W looks good and if the adventure is cheap/good the art doesn't matter to much and B/W is nicer on the printer. 80% of Questsof Doom is better than 80% of the early WoTC stuff and the worst ones are still better than the worst WoTC ones. &nbsp;WoTC is batting just a bit over 60% maybe 70% hits vs average/meh adventures. Probably slightly better than Paizo these days, worse than them if you look at the equivalent amount of time. 50% hits is a good ratio IMHO better than what TSR pulled off (they made some gems and some dud).&nbsp;Adventure deign is more an art form IMHO. The best adventure designers do not work for WoTC (Kobolds, Frog Gods, Paizo, maybe Green Ronin).</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Zardnaar, post: 7425019, member: 6716779"] Not 80% of the good 3pp (Kobolds, Goodman, Frog God, Paizo) probably better than 80% of the DMGuild stuff. Assuming of course you take away the uber production values and look at the adventure. Full colour art is nice but B/W looks good and if the adventure is cheap/good the art doesn't matter to much and B/W is nicer on the printer. 80% of Questsof Doom is better than 80% of the early WoTC stuff and the worst ones are still better than the worst WoTC ones. WoTC is batting just a bit over 60% maybe 70% hits vs average/meh adventures. Probably slightly better than Paizo these days, worse than them if you look at the equivalent amount of time. 50% hits is a good ratio IMHO better than what TSR pulled off (they made some gems and some dud). Adventure deign is more an art form IMHO. The best adventure designers do not work for WoTC (Kobolds, Frog Gods, Paizo, maybe Green Ronin). [/QUOTE]

Verification