Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Damon Griffin" data-source="post: 2663147" data-attributes="member: 3568">Let's say I cast a Rope Trick spell, and with six companions I scurry up the rope into a pocket dimension where &quot;no creature can find [me]&quot;.&nbsp; I pull the rope up after us, and we have a nifty 3'x5' window onto the area below us.&nbsp; Spells can't pass the interface, but no mention is made of material objects.&nbsp; Therefore:1) Can my companions and I fire missile weapons through the window at targets directly below the window?If so, we must presume those targets can fire back, since there is no mention of the interface being one-way (except visually, because the spell description says we can't be found but we can clearly see out.)&nbsp; But since we can't be found:2) Is it reasonable to assume Total Concealment (50% miss chance and attacker must guess at target's location) applies to those of us within the area at the top of the rope?3) Given that we're probably kneeling around a 3'x5' window to shoot out, what fraction of Cover should apply?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Damon Griffin, post: 2663147, member: 3568"] Let's say I cast a Rope Trick spell, and with six companions I scurry up the rope into a pocket dimension where "no creature can find [me]". I pull the rope up after us, and we have a nifty 3'x5' window onto the area below us. Spells can't pass the interface, but no mention is made of material objects. Therefore: 1) Can my companions and I fire missile weapons through the window at targets directly below the window? If so, we must presume those targets can fire back, since there is no mention of the interface being one-way (except visually, because the spell description says we can't be found but we can clearly see out.) But [U]since[/U] we can't be found: 2) Is it reasonable to assume Total Concealment (50% miss chance and attacker must guess at target's location) applies to those of us within the area at the top of the rope? 3) Given that we're probably kneeling around a 3'x5' window to shoot out, what fraction of Cover should apply? [/QUOTE]

Verification