Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Smackpixi" data-source="post: 8745899" data-attributes="member: 7028579">Wasn’t RAW.&nbsp; New RAW seems to be that rollable for one is rollable for all.&nbsp; You‘re arguing about old rules.&nbsp; IF the new rule is that rolling a 20 on a check is a success, it must mean that players should get rolls on things their player couldn’t possibly succeed on.&nbsp; Otherwise, rule is meaningless. Today, I don’t have players roll on things they can’t so.&nbsp; I will probably continue doing that forever.&nbsp; But a 20 is auto success means that I must now allow them to roll on rollable things they couldn’t previously succeed on.No one can jump a 100ft chasm.&nbsp; Impossible.&nbsp; No Roll.&nbsp; But someone could jump a 20 ft chasm, so roll.&nbsp; people keep saying if it’s impossible for the particular character there is no roll, but that’s denying the new 20 success idea.&nbsp; If a 20 is a success on any roll, the only way that has meaning is if everyone gets a roll on possible for someone checks.&nbsp; If before, rolling a 20 to clear the casem still wouldn’t clear it for that character, you just say, nah, but now, for that character rolling a 20 will clear the chasam.&nbsp; So, you have them roll.&nbsp; Again, it all goes back to if it’s a rollable check.&nbsp; 100ft isn’t.&nbsp; 20ft is.&nbsp; So on the 20ft jump under the 20 auto success, everyone can try And everyone has 5% chance of success per nat 20 even if their individual stats say, impossible.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Smackpixi, post: 8745899, member: 7028579"] Wasn’t RAW. New RAW seems to be that rollable for one is rollable for all. You‘re arguing about old rules. IF the new rule is that rolling a 20 on a check is a success, it must mean that players should get rolls on things their player couldn’t possibly succeed on. Otherwise, rule is meaningless. Today, I don’t have players roll on things they can’t so. I will probably continue doing that forever. But a 20 is auto success means that I must now allow them to roll on rollable things they couldn’t previously succeed on. No one can jump a 100ft chasm. Impossible. No Roll. But someone could jump a 20 ft chasm, so roll. people keep saying if it’s impossible for the particular character there is no roll, but that’s denying the new 20 success idea. If a 20 is a success on any roll, the only way that has meaning is if everyone gets a roll on possible for someone checks. If before, rolling a 20 to clear the casem still wouldn’t clear it for that character, you just say, nah, but now, for that character rolling a 20 will clear the chasam. So, you have them roll. Again, it all goes back to if it’s a rollable check. 100ft isn’t. 20ft is. So on the 20ft jump under the 20 auto success, everyone can try And everyone has 5% chance of success per nat 20 even if their individual stats say, impossible. [/QUOTE]

Verification