Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Storminator" data-source="post: 303467" data-attributes="member: 305">Joshua, yes, the number of market share is significant (there's that word again!) to your argument, and I never advocated that you stop using it. I was merely pointing out that Ryan's quote may in fact be entirely accurate, and also totally unrelated to the discussion at hand. I actually said that the quote about all other systems being insignificant shouldn't be used, as we aren't sure what Dancey actually claimed to be insignificant. Was it the next biggest game? Was it all the other games put together? Was it the people that buy those games and NOT D&amp;D as well? We don't know, so we should stop pretending we do.Mostly tho, I'm tired of the bickering. A discussion of the sacred cows of D&amp;D might be interesting. Watching you and Umbran and the occasional other snipe at each other for 3 pages is not. Unfortunately, that's what this thread has become. I don't know about you, but I figured out a long time ago that you and Umbran (and Thorin, what the heck) just aren't going to resolve anything. So I think you should drop it and move on. Whether or not you do isn't up to me, tho, so I'll just have to be done here myself.PS</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Storminator, post: 303467, member: 305"] Joshua, yes, the number of market share is significant (there's that word again!) to your argument, and I never advocated that you stop using it. I was merely pointing out that Ryan's quote may in fact be entirely accurate, and also totally unrelated to the discussion at hand. I actually said that the quote about all other systems being insignificant shouldn't be used, as we aren't sure what Dancey actually claimed to be insignificant. Was it the next biggest game? Was it all the other games put together? Was it the people that buy those games and NOT D&D as well? We don't know, so we should stop pretending we do. Mostly tho, I'm tired of the bickering. A discussion of the sacred cows of D&D might be interesting. Watching you and Umbran and the occasional other snipe at each other for 3 pages is not. Unfortunately, that's what this thread has become. I don't know about you, but I figured out a long time ago that you and Umbran (and Thorin, what the heck) just aren't going to resolve anything. So I think you should drop it and move on. Whether or not you do isn't up to me, tho, so I'll just have to be done here myself. PS [/QUOTE]

Verification