Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="FalcWP" data-source="post: 2855177" data-attributes="member: 16858">Ok.  So, here's a question.  If a 9th level Beguiler takes Extra Spell and picks Blindness/Deafness, what level spell is it?  It isn't on his class list... its a 2nd level Sorcerer/Wizard and Bard spell... but a 3rd level Cleric spell.  I think that's where the whole, "You can pick any spell on any spell list" thing really breaks down - even if you *could* add it to your spell list and spells known list, you can't determine what level spell it is with something like that.  Will that come up with every spell?  No; only a handful have varying levels, and, one would think, fewer still would actually be selected.  But, when your rules interpretation opens up an unanswerable question (which it is, as far as I can see - you would have to house rule things one way or another), then your interpretation is flawed.</blockquote>