Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Saeviomagy" data-source="post: 1342049" data-attributes="member: 5890">[spoiler]Straight to a neat little room where they can interrogate the rogue - he's lying to them.The juggler can't be truthful, because he says the drummers statement "I sometimes lie and sometimes tell the truth" is false - and because the juggler and the drummer already agreed on something, the drummer cannot always lie.The jester cannot be truthful, because he says the piper always lies - the piper made a statement in the beginning that it could be either town, so if either town is right, the piper told the truth. The only person not to speak was the juggler, and we know he's not the truth teller, so it has to be someone else, therefore one of the towns must be right, so the piper is telling the truth and the jester is lyingThe Bear lies right at the beginning, because he makes a patently untrue statement. The Drummer most certainly did say what he said...The piper cannot be truthful, because he says the drummer is always truthful. This is a self-contradicting statement that cannot be true.The drummer cannot be truthful because he says he sometimes lies and he sometimes tells the truth.[/spoiler]</blockquote>