Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Al" data-source="post: 340929" data-attributes="member: 2486">It occurred to me that Sense Motive can sniff out liars, but if someone is telling the truth, unless you play critical failure rules, everyone is going to believe them.  Furthermore, if someone is lying and someone is telling the truth, the truthteller will always win out.  So here's an interesting House Rule: Bluffing the Truth.Bluffing the Truth Strange things happen in fantasy worlds, and some people refuse to believe it even what is true.  As such, it is sometimes necessary to convince people.  The way this works: an incredible event is given a DC.  Your Bluff check (or Diplomacy check*) is subtracted from the DC.  The modified DC is the new DC for the listener's Sense Motive check.  If he fails, he dismisses the claim as too incredible to be true (even though it is).Sample DCs:0: Everyday occurrences.  Going to market, taking the dog for a walk etc.  No one would doubt the veracity of such claims.10: Out of the ordinary.  Your son being kidnapped by goblins, a manticore being seen over the village.  Some skeptics may find these claims dubious.20: Unusual.  This is a clearly unusual event.  A dragon landing in the city centre, or the mayor turning out to be a vampire.  Quite a few people will not believe the average storyteller.30: Highly irregular.  This is a real strain to believe.  A visitation from a deity, a man giving birth, the entire population of a village turning into mushrooms.  Most people will find your claims highly dubious.40: Way out there.  St. Cuthbert and Vecna descending and doing the can-can, Erythnul playing tiddlewinks and crying when he loses.  Very few indeed will find these claims credible.Of course, the DCs are the DM's call.  These are just off-the-top-of-my-head examples.Example: Bill the Farmer has found out that the harmless old woman who lived in the cottage is actually a disguised lich, and relates the tale to the mayor.  The DM sets the DC at 25.  The farmers makes a Diplomacy check and scores a 6.  The mayor now has to make a Sense Motive check DC19.  He rolls a 2, adding his Sense Motive of +6 to make a total of 8, falling far short.  Dismissing Bill, he instructs him sternly to stay off the drink.Truth vs. Lies The skilled liar can pass his lies across even when opposed by someone telling the truth.  This is treated as an opposed roll, but whoever is telling the truth gets a +10 circumstance bonus to his roll, and may use Diplomacy* in place of Bluff.* In both cases, Diplomacy may be used as the character is not actually lying.  Hence, Diplomacy (being the skill to represent eloquent speaking and putting one's case forward) can be used in place of a Bluff check if, and only if, the speaker is telling the truth (or what he perceives to be the truth.)What do you think?</blockquote>

Verification