Book of Erotic Fantasy Preview

JoeGKushner

Adventurer
At Gen Con, Valar Project had a sneak peak at their new adult product, the Book of Erotic Fantasy. This wasn't some cheap flimsy thing either, but a full color, glossy 32 page book that ran for $9.95 giving buyers a good idea of what the rules will be like when the finished product comes out. What I found strange was that this is compatible with 3.5 D&D so it's one of the handful of products (not counting Sword & Sorcery Studio's massive Gen Con Launch) of 3.5 products. In some ways it's a very smart move as it not only helps fund the product but allows people to see what's coming down the line. Still, I can already hear people moaning that they spent $10 on a preview book and want to trade it in.

The book starts off with how the various alignments view sex and love. At first, it struck me as a strange thing to start off with, but the material allows a reader to have some idea of what effect alignments, an artificial role playing tool, can have on a real event, like love or sex. It's pretty obvious in most cases that lawful good people are going to be up front and honest while chaotic neutrals are going to do what they please. It helps reinforce alignment types in different actions and uses small vignettes to illustrate the point further.

My own favorite is probably how the book twists the old local noble rights in the lawful neutral section. See, in this case, it's the young male monk who must go perform on the noble, as opposed to the nobles coming in the middles of the night like in Braveheart.

The important thing to note right off the bat is that the material ranges from soft core with the good alignments to more hard core with the evil ones. The bad news is that right away, I can tell for my group, I would not let this book pass into the hands of about three of my seven players, not because they're under 18, but because they're still teens in their behavior and think that movies like Coyote Ugly and Charlie's Angels are great for all of the t&a. Private opinion, if you're seeing a pg-13 movie for such things, get a clue, rent a porno, go watch a normal movie. Nothing against the old t&a but when it's the focus of the movie, it's moved beyond me.

After the alignments, it moves onto Skills, Feats and Variations. One thing that amused me right away was the optional checks for skills like Appraise, where you can determine how much stamina a partner has or Bluff, to hook up with a partner. Some of the feats provide real benefits, like Kundalini, where you get a +2 bonus to your Wisdom score for 24 hours after having sex for 20 continuous minutes. For those who've wanted an Appearance stat, we've got App, which changes skills like Bluff, Disguise, Intimidate and Gather information to either App, or App or Cha. Bad thing about this is it'd throw off a point buy system which is designed for six stats. Hopefully the book will have more information on how to counter such a factor or what to do with players who already have their 8 charisma orcs and now get to have an 8 charisma and an 8 appearance.

Some mythos have fertility deities and I know one of them at least, “Black Goat with 1,000 Young”, has been in more than one game before. Here, that title falls to Vershnat, a member of the goblin pantheon. Also described is Kaladis, a lawful neutral deity whose duties involve things like marriage.

Those looking for Prestige Classes can choose from the following:

Vestal Virgin: A 5 level PrC that focuses on Chastity and the power gained from purity including such benefits as a unicorn mount.

Disciple of Aaluran: Pleasure seekers, in a 5 level PrC, who strive for both love and sex, gaining access to a Pleasure Prestige Domain. Strange as I've not noticed other publishers using prestige domains for spellcasters but interesting. The bonus feats and ability to disguise oneself are nice bonuses.

Dominator: This is a 10 level PrC and I'll give you one guess what they specialize in. The thing I was pleased with, is it's not just a sex thing here. They want to dominate people and aren't afraid of doing things like embarrassing others, pulling psychological plays, and other methods, to gain that power over another. Hate to say it, but they'd probably be perfect for say, Bane of the Forgotten Realms.

Rake: A 10 level PrC that is roguish in nature and is a combination between a bard, rogue, and some of the courtesan PrCs on the market already.

After the PrCs, we get new domains and spells. The Joining, Perversion (Prestige) and Pleasure (Prestige) domains include special abilities and specific spells. Many of the spells are found in this book but there are quite a few from the PHB like Symbol of Persuasion and Suggestion, from the Pleasure domain.

New spells deal not only with sex but also birth control, both in preventing it and corrupting it. For example, Block the Seed is a 1 day/level spell that makes you sterile while Fiendish Seed causes the child to be born with the half-fiend template. I guess the next question is where's the Angelic Seed? Not all of the spells are such though, take Find a Soulmate, a low level spell that can be used to set a member of the party on the quest for his soulmate or Healing Sphere, a sphere of light that cures damage. A mix of role playing material and sexual pleasure for both camps probably won't please either of them, but those who are just interested in the subject will enjoy all of them.

Chapter Five, Creatures, includes Fallen Cherubs, Pleasure Golems and Greater Succubus. A nice mix of monsters and I hate to say it, but the Scarred Lands beat Anthony to the punch with the Pleasure Golem in their Shalazar book. The Fallen Cherub was an interesting twist, a mean version that sets out to find people who'd probably hate each other and whose hate is pretty justified, getting them into potentially dangerous situations.

One thing I don't like about the book is the art. Ironically enough, it's not because it's 'adult' themed. Not all of the pictures are naked women or anything. It's because, and I'll probably get flamed for this, the pictures often can't compare to the fantasy. What the hell does that mean some may ask. On the cover is a demonic looking woman, very much the temptress. I personally think that Dragon magazine #306, with it's clawed sucubuss, looks better. Or even when looking at Dragon #310 with it's Elmore Cover. Here's the master of the genre with a classic piece featuring two women. Sure, the adventuring swordswoman in the front of the preview is impressive in her stance and bloodied sword, but she doesn't compare to Elmore's work.

And once again, I'll probably get flamed for this, but due to the nature of the clothing some of these models are wearing, when it cuts into their skin, that doesn't look attractive. The blonde on page 4 looks like she's being tortured by her chest piece. When it works, it works best when it looks more fantastic than realistic, like the spellcaster with her back to the reader, facing the woods, but that's my opinion.

Lastly, on the art, it's not just all women and t&a. There are male servitors and male warriors and there is some violent content in here as well. All of it done in a adult context.

The book uses two columns of solid text with a nice stylish border. The material is slick glossy paper and the interior covers are used. With this features, it's very competitively priced.

If you're interested in this subject matter, Valar Project has created a product with high quality productions and a lot of variance in the material that should satisfy not only your basic questions but those you might not have thought to ask.
 

log in or register to remove this ad



This preview just confirms that the book is everything its detractors feared and nothing like the lofty..umm..stuff that was bandied about by Valar and the one of its authors with enough courage to name herself (the fact that it takes courage to be named an author of a book should be telling in and of itself).

I see above pleasure, perversion, how the alignments engage in and view sex (*giggle!*), violent imagery, torture, demon sex, and so on...

There's nothing mature about the subject matter, only a few people foisting their demented sexuality onto the RPG public at large.
 

Sounds interesting. As some of you haven't quite grasped, the game has evolved as the original D&D 1E players have grown up, had families and found D&D a pleasant adult pasttime.

I see this book as having a small place in my campaign. Notably in use with Shelzar (as mentioned in the review) and "Courtesans of Idra," another Scarred Lands feature. The prestige classes are also intriguing, especially the Vestal Virgin, which I would use only in a very rough urban campaign, to add additional contrast.

In general, it will play the same role in my campaign as "Book of Vile Darkness," a sourcebook of ideas that I pick up about once every few months for campaign ideas, as opposed ot the books I grab on a weekly basis. BoVD is hardly vile, by the way. And I doubt this book will be as soul corrupting as some people are making it out to be.

Don't like it? Don't buy it. The D20 world has grown to adulthood and we can care less about this silly fear of the games image. Grow up; the gamers have.
 

"There's nothing mature about the subject matter, only a few people foisting their demented sexuality onto the RPG public at large."

Geez, d20Dwarf, judge much?

I don't exactly see Valar & Co. shoving this book into people's hands at gunpoint. Hell, they charged $10 for a promo. Grow up and learn your POV might just be your own.

Like Gareman said, Don't like it? Don't buy it. And don't stumble around like a fool dancing cheek-to-cheek with your own badly mistuned sense of superiority.
 

Do you like to Roleplay? Not that kind of roleplay, ma'am.

Yup, that’s how our conversation started as I passed by Valar Project, Inc.’s booth at Gencon Indy where they were selling preview copies of their upcoming "Book of Erotic Fantasy." Really, it isn’t my kind, but the more I got to thinking about it, and the more I thought about the ever-so-cute booth babe who chatted with me (and whose picture I’m a complete dingus for not taking), the more I thought I ought to pick it up and take a look. Part curiosity, part desire to help these folks get their book in stores (assuming stores want their book), I plunked down the ten bucks for it. Yes, I actually paid for their advertising material. I’ll send ENWorld a bill.

Caveat 1: My foremost issue with this type of book is that Dungeons and Dragons has already got enough of a bad name with moms and dads across the country. Blah blah blah devil worship blah blah blah suicide pacts blah. It seems to me that this is certainly not the kind of thing that I would have wanted Mom to see in the gaming store when I was a kid. That woulda been the end of that, no doubt. I was assured first that they recognize it is adult material. The webpage specifies that it is for adults only (although perhaps the warning should be more prominently displayed), and younger players were shuttled on past the booth if they lingered too long. Additionally, the actual books will be shrink wrapped or bagged in some way such that idle hands won’t be getting a hold of them while leafing through stores. Sorry folks, no free views for you! However it seems that they are committed to distributing it in a responsible manner, and so long as the gaming stores do their part, this shouldn’t be much worse than the Book of Vile Darkness.

Caveat 2: This is clearly a work meant for adults, and my review will, by necesity, reference certain adult topics. If you’re not an adult, or are squeamish about naughty things, don’t read this review, and don’t buy the book. Above all, don’t email me and tell me I’m going to hell. Please? :)

[Moderator: Sorry. The subject matter of the book does not exempt it from the rules of this site and I have graciously taken the time to filter your review. I will not be so gracious a second time and any further reviews that don't pass muster with ENWorld's general posting policy will be deleted without warning.]

Overall Review

Anyway, here it goes. This isn’t my kind of roleplaying, and I haven’t the slightest idea what to do with it. I really can’t envision myself sitting around a table with a bunch of guys, looking at Bob the GM with a straight face, and trying to seduce him with a "Perform: Sexual Techniques" skill check.

Having said that, if this is the type of thing you can do "in a sensitive, respectful and mature way" (from the book’s introduction), then more power to you and I suspect that you’ll really like this book. You’ll note that there is a 5/5 rating attached to this review, which is something of a misnomer. 5/5 to me means that everyone should go out and buy it, and certainly not everyone should go out and buy it. On the other hand, I think giving it a 3/5 would be inaccurate for people seriously interested in the material, since I think it is pretty durn good. How ’bout we say this: it’s a 4.5/5 or so (rounding up to 5) for anyone who would be interested, and a 0/5 for everyone else.

The rest of the review will go through the various preview chapters in order, citing the high and low points of each. Note that because this was only a preview, there will clearly be more in the book than what I’ve covered here. Consequently, the review will seem somewhat imcomplete. Sorry ’bout that ;)

Character Development and Gods

The Character Development chapter begins with a very well thought out description of how sex plays into the core allignments that players can choose. From the Lawful Good, honorable paladin who is careful to not take liberties not directly offered, to the Chaotic Neutral "It’s all about me" to the Lawful Evil dominator who uses sex as a tool to get what they want, each of the allignments is carefully described, and many have descriptive stories to help delineate the differences.

This is certainly where the roleplay shines, as opposed to the rollplay of feats and skills and the inescapable d20. Subtle differences between the allignments will guide the character’s choices as lover (or something else), and can really help flesh the character out. Allignment is often an overlooked aspect of characters, often simply being "I’m chaotic so demand a reward for my services" or "I’m neutral, so I just don’t care (but will advance the story line anyway because I’m a hero)!" It is good to note that Chaotic Evil is given only a brief description, concluding with, "These aspects of sex are prohibited among all but demonic society and despised by all the other alignments. Book of Erotic Fantasy intentionally omits all but the mention of such heinous acts." That kind of stuff we definitely don’t need in gaming.

The skills and feats section leave me a little less impressed. A lot of squishy skills (such as diplomacy, bluff, and the like) have been overly abstracted in the d20 system in my opinion, and I hate to see "roll a diplomacy check to see if you get past the guards." The new use of the appraise skill to make judgments about the quality of a potential lover seems contrived, especially in any organized roleplay environment. If a character in your game is important enough to sleep with, then I’d expect that to not be an issue, and if the character isn’t important enough, then who cares which one you get into the sack? Craft (sexual toys) seems similarly silly, and as if they were trying too hard to come up with applicable skills. Use of the Perform: burlesque skill could certainly be fun, especially if the bard is using it to facinate opponents in combat, and using Sense Motive to tell if your lover is faithful seems a pretty reasonable extension. Feat-wise, you have the option to become Tantric, allowing you to continue sex for outrageous durations, or be seductive, adding a bonus to all charisma-based skills.

This is where we get into the jokes related to [Moderator: The types of things Eric Gandma doesn't like to hear, Nuff said -Psion] It seems to me that if you’re really roleplaying this kind of stuff, you’re *not* concerned about the dice rolls. If you’re just rolling dice to see if you can extract a certain piece of information from someone you’re trying to seduce, you don’t really need a whole book of this stuff. Thankfully, this is a relatively minor part of the book (and is where the 5/5 drops to 4.5/5 on the overall rating).


The chapter on the Gods is pretty straightforward. There are two presented in the preview copy, each being an aspect of sex that ties to its allignment. The Goblin greater goddess Vershnat (lawful evil) is concerned with the propogation of the species at all cost, expunging weak bloodlines. She is quick to betray those she perceives as weak, regardless of their relationship with her. Kaladis, the Lawful Neutral god of marriage, is unconcerned with issues of love or passion. Similarly, he doesn’t recognize external morality, and is unbothered by polygamy so long as the bonding oaths are taken with full knowledge of the legal regime. "Love should be fostered within a relationship, but is not required if the union is sound, practical, and good for the family and community." Presumably the full version of the book will include a wider variation of gods, such that all the allignments (except CE) are covered and described. Knowing the dogma of a god or goddess is, IMHO, paramount to roleplaying a cleric successfully.


Prestige Classes

There are four Prestige Classes offered in the preview, which seem rougly applicable to paladin/spellcaster/rogue, and are by and large well thought out and developed. The Rake is likely the most universal of the PrCs, in that I could see her easily being something used in non-sexual campaigns as well as sexual ones, but all of them clearly well designed and have abilities and bonuses intuitively appropriate to their backgrounds.

First is the Vestal Virgin, the chaste fighter with the Unicorn companion. It’s interesting that this type of character would be in this book, considering that her philosophy runs counter to most of the rest of the material in the book. The level progression offers full BAB, some pretty buff fortitude and will save bonuses, and gains additional bonuses against enchantments and disease/poison. They also gain spellcasting ability from the cleric spell list, as well as the Good and Protection domains. In a campaign where sex doesn’t take a center role, this class may have a touch too much oompf to it, but in one where it does, I can see giving up pleasures of the flesh being a fair trade for the granted abilities.

The Disciple of Aaluran - My Body is a Temple...come and worship! Disciples are most often clerics of love gods and goddesses, who believe that sex is the purpose of existence. As such, their class abilities are tied towards offering pleasure to others. They gain access to a new prestige domain, the Pleasure domain (see the spellcasting page), have wizard/sorcerer BAB, and gain the ability to radiate goodwill (like the Sanctuary spell) or even cripple an opponent with lust. Another well thought out class.

The Dominator is your typical bondage guy - Iron Will and 8 ranks in intimidate are some of the prereqs for the class. Again, he has only the wizard BAB, but as he grows in power, in addition to increasing in his current class’s spell progression, he gains bonuses to intimidate and will saves, as well as the ability to cast dominate person and cause intense pain with a touch. This would certainly be an interesting class to roleplay in a group of adventurers, for someone who could pull it off.

Lastly, the Rake is the seductress, and a reasonably good counterpart to the Spymaster in Song and Silence. She gains sneak attack ability like rogues, but also the bardic ability to facinate. Additionally, the rake gains various and sundry bonuses to Diplomacy and Sense Motive, [Moderator: Some of which deal with nonhuman creatures -Psion]


Spellcasting

The spellcasting section of this book has a good mix of old and new spells in the new prestige domains, and a lot of fun spells to try out on the baddies (or goodies!). The funniest spells are Reverse Gender (I remember in an old campaign I played in that was one of the negative effects of the Wand or Orcus. Good clean fun, that was!), and a new version of the Command spell (...) [Moderator - And other sexual related spells - 'nuff said] (...) whereas some are pretty damn cool - Lifebond (when cast on your true love, you evermore know their exact relative position to you, as well as their condition) and Kiss of Life (a raise dead for Bards and Sorcerers with an decreased likelihood of losing a level the more intimate the relationship the caster has with the dead person).

Again, there is a lot of good material to work with in this section, assuming you are in a sex-related campaign (and some spells, like Lifebond or Kiss of Life are universal to other campaigns). But, as in other parts of this book, there’s not enough meat applicable to a more traditional campaign that fades to black when the covers come up.


Creatures

There are several nice creatures in this section, well thought out and well designed for mischeif.

The first, the fallen cherub, is a nasty little bugger who, unlike his unfallen cousin, delights in causing mischief instead of love. His arrows can inspire hatred of your greatest love, or obsessive lust of the first creature you see. He can even send you on a gaes/quest to do things that would make your old frat brothers blush. These would make excellent plot devices in just about any campaign, and have enough teeth to bite that fighter who tries to smite them.

The pleasure golem is Book of Erotic Fantasy’s answer to Bride of Frankenstein. Created not for combat but for pleasure, its primary ability is to change its gender and appearance at will, thus better enabling it to fulfil the desires of its current user.

Lastly, the Greater Succubus is a leaner, meaner version of the normal Succubus.

Last Thoughts

OK, so that’s the scoop on the hard stuff on the inside of the book. One other thing worth noting is that the preview book uses all photography not illustrations. The photographs are high quality, and excellent. I’ll admit that the guy with the rings in his nipples chained to his wrists (for the Lawful Evil descriptor) is a little freaky, and the pleasure golem looks like something from a slasher film. However, some of the photographs are just outright beautiful. Obviously, you should be aware that there’s full frontal, though I understand that there won’t be any hard core.

In summary, I’ll reiterate that if you want sex to take a more prominant role in your gaming, you really ought to buy this book. There is plenty of good stuff to really get your characters into the mood and spirit of that kind of a game, and I would expect that the final version of the book will have more of the same high quality. I had the pleasure of getting my copy autographed by the author and the photographer, and while I got the distinct impression that I didn’t quite cut the mustard in terms of cool-factor from the photographer (from the look he gave me, heh), the author, Gwendolyn F. M. Kestrel, seemed very nice, and very eager for people to read and enjoy her book. I suspect that I won’t be buying it when it comes out in October, but if the author wanted to send me a free copy care of the Safehouse, I certainly wouldn’t send it back. ;)

Llabak Tharr
www.thesafehouse.org

[Final Moderator Note: Saying you wouldn't even by the book this advertises does NOT sound like a 5 review to me. -Psion]
 

scupper wrote:
"Grow up and learn your POV might just be your own.
(...) And don't stumble around like a fool dancing cheek-to-cheek with your own badly mistuned sense of superiority."

Please cease and desist personal attacks and contain all commentary to the content of the book. And remember, Eric's Grandma lives on.

ADThanksVANCE, Psion,
Reviews moderator.
 

I think that you should take notice that this is still Morrus' news and reviews site, and a few of your tongue-in-cheek comments would make my Grandma blush. I will be editing them out and will ask you to refrain from such vulgarity in the future.
 

D'oh sorry 'bout that. I thought I had done a pretty decent job of keeping it PG-13, but didn't know there was a Grandma rule in effect ;) I'll make sure I keep that in mind in the future! My apologies.

However, I need to take issue with your final moderator note:

[Final Moderator Note: Saying you wouldn't even by the book this advertises does NOT sound like a 5 review to me. -Psion]

because I don't think that's at all fair. There are many things that I won't buy, but can appreciate the value of. I don't play any Star Wars RPG, but that doesn't keep me from saying I think it's a good (or bad) product. With a limited gaming budget, I can't buy everything, and I'm not going to spend money on a product that I will never use in my own campaigns, playing 99% RPGA games.

Similarly, I could probably write a very nice review about a Porche, but with limited (heh) automobile budget, I'm not going to buy a Boxter next month. I could write a nice review on why one vodka is better than another, but not having taken a drink in 8 years, I'm not going to go out and buy some tomorrow.

I think that being able to be fair and unbiased regarding a product you are reviewing is an important halmark of journalism, and just because I don't personally have a use for the product in my own life, if I'm able to see how someone else would, I should be honest about that.

Respectfully,
Llabak Tharr
 

Remove ads

Top