Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="RangerWickett" data-source="post: 305908" data-attributes="member: 63">Well, one of the options that I think might be good was this one:In each category, ask two questions.&nbsp; First, have the voter click on a tab for each of the products in that category that they are familiar enough with that they consider themselves informed.&nbsp; Second, ask them to vote for which one they think is best out of those.Then, calculate the 'number of votes' in this way:&nbsp; &quot;Number of votes for product&quot; divided by &quot;Number of people who felt qualified to judge.&quot;So say the ABC Press's Book of Crossdressing and WotC's Flumphs of the Multiverse[/u] are both nominated for best interior art.&nbsp; Of the people who vote, 50 say that they have seen the interior art for the Book of Crossdressing, and feel qualified to judge.&nbsp; Of that, 40 people vote for it.In comparison, 1000 people say that they have seen the interior art of Flumphs of the Multiverse, but only 200 people vote for it.&nbsp; Normally, the WotC book would win, with 200 votes vs. 40.&nbsp; However, ABC Press's book impressed 80% of those who read it, while WotC's book only impressed 20%.&nbsp; Thus, ABC would win.Just a thought.&nbsp; How does it sound?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="RangerWickett, post: 305908, member: 63"] Well, one of the options that I think might be good was this one: In each category, ask two questions. First, have the voter click on a tab for each of the products in that category that they are familiar enough with that they consider themselves informed. Second, ask them to vote for which one they think is best out of those. Then, calculate the 'number of votes' in this way: "Number of votes for product" divided by "Number of people who felt qualified to judge." So say the ABC Press's [u]Book of Crossdressing[/u] and WotC's [b]Flumphs of the Multiverse[/u] are both nominated for best interior art. Of the people who vote, 50 say that they have seen the interior art for the Book of Crossdressing, and feel qualified to judge. Of that, 40 people vote for it. In comparison, 1000 people say that they have seen the interior art of Flumphs of the Multiverse, but only 200 people vote for it. Normally, the WotC book would win, with 200 votes vs. 40. However, ABC Press's book impressed 80% of those who read it, while WotC's book only impressed 20%. Thus, ABC would win. Just a thought. How does it sound?[/b] [/QUOTE]

Verification