Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Ruvion" data-source="post: 1596475" data-attributes="member: 878">In the 3.5e PHB (the spells section page 207) under break enchantment, it says it can &quot;reverse even an instantaneous effect, such as flesh to stone.&quot;...it goes on to say that if it is a spell not dispellable by dispel magic then it does not work if it's a spell higher than 5th level...and flesh to stone just so happens to be a 6th level spell....another confounding matter is the fact that stone to flesh is a 6th level spell that has a chance of killing a previously petrified subject when bringing him back...when compared to the 5th level break enchantment that has no such fatal chance of killing the target you sort of wonder if the R&amp;D slipped up on the written portion of the break enchantment spell.I tend to see it as an error on the grounds that break enchantment cannot get rid of flesh to stone...but wondering if there are differing opinions on this issue?!</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Ruvion, post: 1596475, member: 878"] In the 3.5e PHB (the spells section page 207) under [i]break enchantment[/i], it says it can "reverse even an instantaneous effect, such as [i]flesh to stone[/i]." ...it goes on to say that if it is a spell not dispellable by [i]dispel magic[/i] then it does not work if it's a spell higher than 5th level...and [i]flesh to stone[/i] just so happens to be a 6th level spell. ...another confounding matter is the fact that [i]stone to flesh[/i] is a 6th level spell that has a chance of killing a previously petrified subject when bringing him back...when compared to the 5th level [i]break enchantment[/i] that has no such fatal chance of killing the target you sort of wonder if the R&D slipped up on the written portion of the [i]break enchantment[/i] spell. I tend to see it as an error on the grounds that [i]break enchantment[/i] cannot get rid of [i]flesh to stone[/i]...but wondering if there are differing opinions on this issue?! [/QUOTE]

Verification