Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Infiniti2000" data-source="post: 3642094" data-attributes="member: 31734">But, then DreamChaser's argument has nothing to do with this question.&nbsp; Neither the target point nor the starting point nor the place of the effect is contained within the AMF.&nbsp;In fact, I did, but I'm guessing you have me on ignore?No, it doesn't.&nbsp; There's a difference between preventing you from using a spell while in an AMF and using a spell within an AMF.&nbsp; Your interpretation on used within is not necessarily the correct one.&nbsp;It's a barrier, sure, but certainly not solid.&nbsp; Are you unable to walk from inside to the outside of an AMF?&nbsp; Are you unable to cast spells through a magic circle vs. (alignment)?&nbsp; It also evokes a barrier.&nbsp; Your argument here is specious.&nbsp;I've answered this above, but the rule actually says (from one interpretation) that you cannot use a spell/magic effect within the AMF.&nbsp; It does not say that you cannot use a spell/magical effect outside the AMF.&nbsp; Remember, in our case, the effect occurs entirely outside the AMF, from the starting point to the target point.&nbsp; It never originates, ends up, passes through, or is otherwise used inside the AMF.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Infiniti2000, post: 3642094, member: 31734"] But, then DreamChaser's argument has nothing to do with this question. Neither the target point nor the starting point nor the place of the effect is contained within the AMF. In fact, I did, but I'm guessing you have me on ignore? No, it doesn't. There's a difference between preventing you from using a spell [B]while in[/B] an AMF and using a spell [B]within[/B] an AMF. Your interpretation on used within is not necessarily the correct one. It's a barrier, sure, but certainly not solid. Are you unable to walk from inside to the outside of an AMF? Are you unable to cast spells through a magic circle vs. (alignment)? It also evokes a barrier. Your argument here is specious. I've answered this above, but the rule actually says (from one interpretation) that you cannot use a spell/magic effect within the AMF. It does not say that you cannot use a spell/magical effect outside the AMF. Remember, in our case, the effect occurs entirely outside the AMF, from the starting point to the target point. It never originates, ends up, passes through, or is otherwise used inside the AMF. [/QUOTE]

Verification