Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Tilla the Hun (work)" data-source="post: 1168708" data-attributes="member: 14214">So I must ask if a consensus has been reached as to the usage of the terms 'continuous', 'unbroken' and 'vertical'?Now granted as a GM, I'll just point to 'wall' and ask how a mandelbrot (or grate) constitutes a flat, unbroken, wall <img src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f642.png" class="smilie smilie--emoji" loading="lazy" width="64" height="64" alt=":)" title="Smile&nbsp; &nbsp; :)"&nbsp; data-smilie="1"data-shortname=":)" />But as a player, I'd certainly push the point and ask what constituted flat, vertical, unbroken, and continuous??I like the monofilament walls of force...&nbsp; But as a GM, a strand of anything 1 molecule wide is a strand, not a wall.The grates I might allow - with multiple castings, each casting constituting one of the lines - but probably not.&nbsp; That's a grate, not a wall.&nbsp; That's a line, not a wall.A wall must divide one area from another.&nbsp; Thus, my minimums would be set at 5' by 5'.&nbsp; Now all of that said...&nbsp; Any reason why a wizard couldn't research LINE OF FORCE or POINT OF FORCE and/or use sculpt spell metamagicks on WALL OF FORCE and accomplish most of what was bandied about here?Also, if it is immobile, with respect to what perspective?&nbsp; Careful if you say caster, cuz then they could argue that the 'vertical' component is with respect to the caster as well..</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Tilla the Hun (work), post: 1168708, member: 14214"] So I must ask if a consensus has been reached as to the usage of the terms 'continuous', 'unbroken' and 'vertical'? Now granted as a GM, I'll just point to 'wall' and ask how a mandelbrot (or grate) constitutes a flat, unbroken, wall :) But as a player, I'd certainly push the point and ask what constituted flat, vertical, unbroken, and continuous?? I like the monofilament walls of force... But as a GM, a strand of anything 1 molecule wide is a strand, not a wall. The grates I might allow - with multiple castings, each casting constituting one of the lines - but probably not. That's a grate, not a wall. That's a line, not a wall. A wall must divide one area from another. Thus, my minimums would be set at 5' by 5'. Now all of that said... Any reason why a wizard couldn't research LINE OF FORCE or POINT OF FORCE and/or use sculpt spell metamagicks on WALL OF FORCE and accomplish most of what was bandied about here? Also, if it is immobile, with respect to what perspective? Careful if you say caster, cuz then they could argue that the 'vertical' component is with respect to the caster as well.. [/QUOTE]

Verification