Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Stalker0" data-source="post: 4269112" data-attributes="member: 5889">What I'm saying is that people were starting to go off and compare all sorts of fighter powers with each other. Its one thing to compare a fighter power to twin strike or careful shot, it gives us a measure of CS or TS's power. Its another to compare two powers that have nothing to do with CS or TS. That's a valid discussion....for another thread.As far as setting the roles for the two powers, I do agree that CS and TS in a lot of ways do the same thing, but there are ways to give them different niches.In the attack +3, 1[W] + dex model I gave above, CS becomes a damage attack. This is the power I use if I want damage from my at will. TS becomes your accuracy power, this is the at-will I use if I really want to hit this turn (like killing mooks, where damage doesn't matter), or if I need to hit two people, etc.However, I really liked the suggestion of making careful shot 1[W] + str (or dex) + wisdom. That fits with wisdom as a secondary stat for the ranger, which none of the other at wills do. And it fits with careful shot being a single powerful attack vs twin strike being your low damage high accuracy attack.I'll run some numbers on that later and see how it balances out.</blockquote>