Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Minicol" data-source="post: 2011505" data-attributes="member: 17308">Hello Folks !This is my first review, and english is not my native language, so please be indulgent with me.This is a playtest review !Carnival is a 80 pages softbound book, written by Scott Charlton, an recurrent author for Living Arcanis, the RPGA Living campaign set in the World of Arcanis. It is playable both within living arcanis and in home play.For those who dont know Arcanis, think Ancient Times and Roman Empire with a rich mythology and an original take on fantasy classics.Carnival of Swords is subtitled "an adventurer's guide to old Coryan".Roughly half of the book is a description of the town of Old Coryan, the old quarter and historical center of the much larger metropolis of Grand Coryan, capitol of the Coryan Empire, the largest country in the Arcanis world. It describes the various areas of the city, from the ghettos of the Myrantian minority to the lofty heights of the patricians quarters.The second part is the adventure. It is a city based adventure, with a heavy emphasis on ROLE rather than ROLL playing, with a strong mystery theme. The adventure is long and can be played in about 10 hours.  It takes place within a carnival and is faithful to the atmosphere of carnivals in ancient times. Sufficiently so to offend some of my more prudish players, but it means some research was done. The atmosphere is really well rendered out.There are about three parts:Part 1 is a murder mysteryPart 2 is an enquiry about an elven (elorii in Arcanis) Artefact.Part 3 unveils a dire conspiracy plot where the players have been the pawn in part 1 and 2, but thankfully, they might have an opportunity to understand what is going on and beat the BBEG.For those who value role-play above dice-rolling, this is a GREAT adventure. I played it with a group of six players, and in that group, five were ecstatic, and one hated it. Afyer discussing it with the problem player, he said that the main reason is that the other five stole the adventure from him, depriving him of the spotlights. So, all said, it is an adventure with a lot of potential, almost able to rival with "power behind the throne" for warhammer.What else can I say ? Art is B&W, but you are not really buying it for the art.The only reason why it doesn't deserve more as a mark, is that I feel that with so rich a setting, the author could have done even better. I hope he sets to writing a sequel. If you have any cash for a hamburger, you must have this book instead !All comments welcome, if you have anything to say, you can email me at : francois.michel12@wanadoo.frregards</blockquote>

Verification