Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Jackinthegreen" data-source="post: 5704522" data-attributes="member: 6678119">As already mentioned in perhaps more words, the act itself of casting a spell is not magical.&nbsp; The action is performed and wasted after all.&nbsp; The effect of the spell is magical though, unless otherwise noted.The origination point is almost universally considered to be the caster.&nbsp; This, however, could lead to some interesting circumstances.&nbsp; What part of the caster?&nbsp; What happens when the caster is in the AMF, but his hands (or other body parts applicable) are not and he casts a somatic spell?&nbsp; One could argue a Small or Medium creature standing on the edge of an AMF could cast under such circumstances, since they have 5 foot reach after all.Such an interpretation would mean the origin of a spell is based off its casting components.&nbsp; A verbal and somatic spell would require someone's respective sources to be outside an AMF.&nbsp; What about material components or foci?&nbsp; Those probably have to be outside the AMF as well.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Jackinthegreen, post: 5704522, member: 6678119"] As already mentioned in perhaps more words, the act itself of casting a spell is not magical. The action is performed and wasted after all. The effect of the spell is magical though, unless otherwise noted. The origination point is almost universally considered to be the caster. This, however, could lead to some interesting circumstances. What part of the caster? What happens when the caster is in the AMF, but his hands (or other body parts applicable) are not and he casts a somatic spell? One could argue a Small or Medium creature standing on the edge of an AMF could cast under such circumstances, since they have 5 foot reach after all. Such an interpretation would mean the origin of a spell is based off its casting components. A verbal and somatic spell would require someone's respective sources to be outside an AMF. What about material components or foci? Those probably have to be outside the AMF as well. [/QUOTE]

Verification