Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="kinem" data-source="post: 2845211" data-attributes="member: 24234">CB: I will edit my character in the RG, posting a retooled version.  If I want to carry a number of nonmagical quivers with a different type of arrow in each, will that be OK?  What is the limit to the number of quivers that I could use at once?  Could I bundle up reserve quivers for storage in a bag?Voadam:  Sympathetic magic is a far better explanation than "the DMG only mentions arrows", but it still doesn't make sense, especially the strange mechanic CB came up with where if even a pebble happens to fall into an empty quiver, it will not be possible to put any intact arrows into that compartment.  Or, if an arrow head falls off inside, suddenly it is not an arrow and all remaining arrows are ejected out of the quiver, 'cause she doesn't allow mixing.  No wizard would intend an item he creates for his fighter buddy to work that way.  Besides, while I enjoy fantasy, I guess I consider it a subgenre of sci-fi and want a bit of logic in there.Mellubb:  I am well aware of the HHH (and thoroughly familiar with all core rules items), and likely will trade in for one, but it is not really what I wanted.  I wanted a normal QoE that works the way it should work, the way I always interpreted it, with the otherwise useless larger compartments available for storing other items of small width, and no BS about the exact wording in the DMG not mentioning other items - the books are poorly written and everyone should realize that by now.   I did NOT request a changed version of the Quiver, just a normal one!  CB completely changed the item from what it should be and what I thought it was when I purchased it, so I no longer want it.  The changes she made don't make sense and therefore ruin the flavor of a simulated world that our PCs can move about in and interact with.Mellubb, while I have stated my views here, I have not argued with her decision.  I don't like the call, but it's her call, and that's that.  I did NOT say to her "No, you can't do that".  I do not contest the fact that in her game, that's the way the QoE works.  All I did is trade it in since I wouldn't buy an item like that.  I already said that I would 'drive on' by trading it in, and if you've read the OOC before posting, you already knew that before telling me to.And, Mellubb - I don't like your attitude.  You said you were not trying to be rude, and that is probably true, but you sure weren't trying not to be rude.  You acted like some kind of know-it-all, and quite unjustifiably.</blockquote>

Verification