Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="CanadienneBacon" data-source="post: 2845284" data-attributes="member: 11146">kinem, you may benefit from knowing that though those words appear in Eydis's post, they aren't hers.&nbsp; That's Mellubb posting--I assume he forgot that Eydis was logged on during his lunch break today.While I definitely do not concur that a QoE is intended to hold anything other than, as Voadam stated, items the general size and shape of arrows, javelins, bows, spears, or staffs, I was willing to re-tool the Quiver to meet what you described as your needs.&nbsp; Your ideas about the mechanics of this game appear to be VERY different than mine.&nbsp; You took issue with the PHB rule that the first set of clothing costs nothing and has no weight.&nbsp; I changed the rule to keep you content, despite it adversely affecting the encumbrance of several PCs.&nbsp; You have taken issue with the DMG description and my interpretation of how a Quiver should function.&nbsp; I changed the Quiver to more closely match your desire for how it should work.&nbsp; You then promptly didn't like what I offered and wanted to ditch it.&nbsp; I said okay, swap it.&nbsp; I don't think Mellubb was very diplomatic in his word choice and therefore can't agree with his sentiment as expressed in this thread, but I also don't like players who push.&nbsp; I'm done messing with mechanics to please players only to have players declare that my ideas are unsuitable.&nbsp; I offer you an olive branch, kinem.&nbsp; I declared before this game started, during recruitment, that I was basically a core-rules only sort of DM.&nbsp; If my DMing style isn't to your liking, I understand and you're welcome to leave.&nbsp; You're also welcome to stay.&nbsp; Prixo is an excellent character and I have looked forward to reading your posts for him.&nbsp; If you elect to continue on with this game, it seems that you may need to prepare yourself for future DM rulings that aren't to your taste.&nbsp; If you feel you're able to ask a question, and perhaps in your case it might be better done via e-mail, without pushing me to see your point of view then, again, stay on with this campaign and let's all have a good time.We can hereby ditch the mechanic I gave out on Monday the 22nd with regard to a QoE.&nbsp; The Quiver will function for arrows, javelins, spears, staffs, and bows (and, as the DMG says, any other similar ranged weapon items).Anything more on this particular subject should please be addressed to me via e-mail.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="CanadienneBacon, post: 2845284, member: 11146"] kinem, you may benefit from knowing that though those words appear in Eydis's post, they aren't hers. That's Mellubb posting--I assume he forgot that Eydis was logged on during his lunch break today. While I definitely do not concur that a QoE is intended to hold anything other than, as Voadam stated, items the general size and shape of arrows, javelins, bows, spears, or staffs, I was willing to re-tool the Quiver to meet what you described as your needs. Your ideas about the mechanics of this game appear to be VERY different than mine. You took issue with the PHB rule that the first set of clothing costs nothing and has no weight. I changed the rule to keep you content, despite it adversely affecting the encumbrance of several PCs. You have taken issue with the DMG description and my interpretation of how a Quiver should function. I changed the Quiver to more closely match your desire for how it should work. You then promptly didn't like what I offered and wanted to ditch it. I said okay, swap it. I don't think Mellubb was very diplomatic in his word choice and therefore can't agree with his sentiment as expressed in this thread, but I also don't like players who push. I'm done messing with mechanics to please players only to have players declare that my ideas are unsuitable. I offer you an olive branch, kinem. I declared before this game started, during recruitment, that I was basically a core-rules only sort of DM. If my DMing style isn't to your liking, I understand and you're welcome to leave. You're also welcome to stay. Prixo is an excellent character and I have looked forward to reading your posts for him. If you elect to continue on with this game, it seems that you may need to prepare yourself for future DM rulings that aren't to your taste. If you feel you're able to ask a question, and perhaps in your case it might be better done via e-mail, without pushing me to see your point of view then, again, stay on with this campaign and let's all have a good time. We can hereby ditch the mechanic I gave out on Monday the 22nd with regard to a QoE. The Quiver will function for arrows, javelins, spears, staffs, and bows (and, as the DMG says, any other similar ranged weapon items). Anything more on this particular subject should please be addressed to me via e-mail. [/QUOTE]

Verification